I ordered from Pop’s last night for the first time after hearing from a few people that they were really good. We got a small meatball and sausage pizza and a medium pepperoni pizza with mild wings and garlic knots. First, they use homemade, fresh ingredients which automatically gives them favor for not relying on canned garbage but the quality did not necessarily translate into taste. The pizza was good so there’s no complaints there it just didn’t have that real appeal to make you want to stuff another slice in when you’re already full. I would put Pop’s at the upper end of the middle of the pack not yet having achieved elite pizza status. The garlic knots and wings were also good but those are two items that are almost the same everywhere you go so I’m focusing just on their main specialty. I really wanted to like these guys more because they seem friendly and delivery was punctual but it was not to be. All in all you’re not going wrong ordering a pie from them but there are better non-chain options out there.
Joshua A.
Place rating: 4 Cohoes, NY
I like the pizza but I am crazy about the subs! Fresh quality ingredients. I keep going back. Can not wait until nicer weather because they are open for lunch in the summer!
Dehna D.
Place rating: 3 Wappingers Falls, NY
Second visit. This time for a fresh white pie which wasn’t winning any awards but didn’t provoke my gag reflex either. Not in my top five.
Josh M.
Place rating: 5 Watervliet, NY
All i have had from there is the fried Oreos and they are amazing. Im hoping sometime in the near future i order from there because when you walk in the door it smells awesome, if you park in front of the shop you can smell it all and it makes your mouth water i wish i had more money to try a lot more but everything is priced really good they have good deals and they have like a coupon thing in the menu so everything about this place is awesome i highly recommend it to everyone. Also they have free delivery for orders $ 10 or more so pretty much you get free delivery all the time depending on what you get.
Sarah Y.
Place rating: 1 Waterford, NY
Worst pizza I ever had in my entire life. The top of it was slightly burnt, and the pizza tasted«off». Plus it looked like a child had colored on the inside of the box with a crayon. My boyfriend and I were put off of pizza for awhile after we tried this place.(I also had fried dough from them in our order which was good… but the pizza was so disgusting it didn’t make up for it, not even a little.) Do not waste your money. Order from Micks or anywhere but here. Yucky. Bleck.
Peter G.
Place rating: 2 Waterford, NY
Their pizza gives me smelly farts everytime. It taste alright though.
Frank Z.
Place rating: 3 Gaithersburg, MD
Good stuff. It’s far from the best I’ve ever had, but Pop’s makes a pretty damn good pizza. Even better, they do a special every Tuesday: 8-cut pizzas are only $ 5. I like it!
Mike L.
Place rating: 4 Latham, NY
I was really craving some fried dough and couldn’t think of anywhere to get it. After doing a quick search Pop’s came up. I remembered a co-worker recommending this place for their Large Cheese Pizza deal as well. They were fast and the dough was HUGE. It filled a large pizza box and was only $ 5. The girl at the counter was super friendly too. Definitely want to check out the rest of their menu now.
Brian L.
Place rating: 5 Cohoes, NY
This is my go to pizza and wings joint. Their pizza sauce and dough are delicious and their toppings are generous and fresh. I like everything from their simply pepporoni pizza to their specialty pizzas. Also, their boneless buffalo wings are just the best. I will note that their«hot» sauce isn’t that hot, so if you typically like a «medium» heat I suggest upgrading. I’ve never got that creative with ordering their other items, but for pizza and wings you can’t miss with Pop’s.