Murray Hill Market

This place is so wonderful I don’t want anyone else to find out about it but I’m posting this anyway because I just have to! The employees and owner are super friendly and helpful. Food is fresh, delicious, and authentic. And what’s even better is they deliver – which is speedy and also free. :) I’m a frequent consumer of their yummy fried eggplant slices!

This is one of the best parts of living in Little Italy. I love having a neighborhood grocery store right down the street. Their sandwiches are spectacular and their beer/​wine selection is pretty solid. While groceries (milk, eggs, etc.) are somewhat pricey, it is worth it (to me) to not have to leave the neighborhood for 1 or 2 small items. They also don’t put prices on anything except their prepared foods, so it’s always a bit of a «surprise!» when you go to check out.

When first looking at the menu, I thought I would hate this place. I’m not big into Italian or sandwiches but after finding a Groupon I thought «why not?».
Now I can’t stop going back.
The roasted turkey breast sandwich was great. The perfect meat to bread ratio and was super fresh– even though I strolled in at 8:00pm.
I also have opted to do my grocery shopping here which is a big added bonus. They have the essentials, which is all I really need. It’s great that they have fresh produce and they freeze their past soups to buy in big containers. That’s the best. I bought the Vegetable Tortilla, stored it in my fridge for a month and when I heated it up, it tasted like it had just been made.
Next stop here: Some of that yummy looking wine.

Great place to eat lunch at with friendly and prompt staff. I got a portobello mushroom with spinach and Gorgonzola, for about four dollars. It was very satisfying. On the premises, you can eat at tables inside or out. I wasn’t a fan of the coffee though.

Awesome eggplant parm — served correctly with provolone, not mozzarella. The bread was excellent, too — an unexpected surprise. The owner/​operators are wonderful, and there are a few places to sit upstairs. Highly recommended!

Love MHM. Michelle and Billy are so knowledgeable and friendly. The food selection and variety is amazing. Everything is fresh out of the oven! A must for any Clevelander east or west !

Delicious! Our deli sandwiches were 9 on a scale of 10. The store was busy so had to wait a bit, and was totally worth it. We ordered for takeout Asian Philly – roast beef, bok choy, sriracha and teriyaki sauces, and cheese; and BLT – fried pancetta, Brie, roasted garlic, arugula, and tomato; both on warm buttery crunchy boat-​shaped buns. The store had lots of extras one might need, plus warm foods, cold salads, beer, wine and Jeni’s. A must go-​to when passing through Little Italy.

I wish there was a corner store like this in my neighborhood. They have a small but solid beer selection, arguably best sandwiches in Cleveland, Jeni’s Ice Cream and wonderful service. My favorite sandwich thus far was the Porchetta. I recommend the deluxe Italian and Asian Philly too. I did not mind waiting for them to prepare my lunch. The legendary J-​Dilla was playing on the stereo followed up by Ohio’s own RJD2. Excellent instrumental music to listen to. The 3 meatballs for $ 5 is a great deal.

I love this place! I’ve tried most things on the menu but the porchetta sandwich is by far my fave. Savory pork in a wonderful fresh baguette topped with sautéed kale and Parmesan. I love sitting up top of the grocery and watching the little Italian deli experience happen below. I love this place!

I’m afraid if I write a review, people will flock here and I’ll be out of a sandwich supplier! I love how quaint and personal this grocery store/​restaurant/​deli is. The sandwiches are a must try. The Rotisserie Turkey Breast sandwich and Meatball Sub are my favorites, but I aim to try them all (multiple times). They prepare them right in front of you… fresh. So sometimes, they can take a few minutes but the wait is easily forgotten when you take that first bite. They also have a mean dried fruit mix and a good selection of interesting sodas. They have bar style seating upstairs and one large table. During warmer months, they have outdoor patio seating.
The only reason I’m giving 4 stars is because I most recently tried the Porchetta, and found it to be slightly salty for my taste and a little heavy on the kale. But that was only one visit out of many. I’ll definitely be back!

The owners here are great, super friendly. Prices are a little high but that’s the price you pay for convenience. We still shop here!

Amazing. I love this place.
Incredible ham and bean soup, eggplant LIGHTLY breaded with tomato sauce and provolone, zucchini fritters, Italian BLT.
In a pinch or an emergency, they deliver. I’ve experienced both.

The staff is so friendly and welcoming! The food is so delicious and fresh! I live three doors down from this adorable gem and I am here all the time!
True, it’s not where you would go for all your groceries, but for an odd or end it’s perfect and so convenient! Don’t feel like cooking anything tonight? That’s okay! The market’s food is better than anything I could ever make!

This is such a hidden gem in Little Italy! It’s not only a convenience store stocked up with anything you’ll need from aspirin to laundry detergent, but it also has some fresh fruits/​veggies! My favorite parts of this market are the unbeatable friendly service and the absolutely delicious sandwiches. I love both the Prochetta and the Prime Rib sandwiches. They’re $ 8.50 each and come with soooo much MEAT! Definitely worth the price :) They also have quite a selection of Italian sodas! I love pairing my sandwiches with the Sanpellegrino blood orange soda. YUM!
They have a loyalty club now, where if you spend $ 50, you’ll get $ 5 off! Although they don’t have cards yet, they will make a note on your receipt, so make sure you bring this up if you want to save some money :)

Murray Hill Market gets 5 stars for their amazing personable service and neighborhood feel. My team met there for a lunch meeting. The owner is so super friendly and enthusiastic about their food, and their food is GOOD. She gave me a few samples of their freshly grilled fish so I could see what I might like for a sandwich. I loved their salmon as well as their crusted tilapia. I ended up with the crusted tilapia sandwich, but will go for the salmon next time! They also feature local goods, like Little Italy pasta sauce as well as Polish desserts (called snoogle.)
This place is perfect for outdoor patio hangouts and meetings. There is a small space on the upstairs level with a table, but it’s not for large parties. I’m definitely coming back while the weather is still nice.
I appreciate this market overall for their focus on local & fresh goods and their friendly service!

I like this kind of place, cute little local supermarket, with just about everything you would need for a last minute bite or ingredient. They’ve got all the elements I love in this kind of place: chalkboard with daily specials, produce right at the entrance, everything is red brick and wood, staff wearing aprons, a deli with all kinds of yummies. My favorite is the spicy sausage stuffing wrapped in banana peppers (I wish they took out the seeds though, cause it can be a little too heated at times). The daily food keeps me coming back as I want to see what they will dish out next. It is and certainly tastes like home cooking (made with love, as they say). And the staff is very friendly
The only negatives is that price may be a little jacked up (that’s expected from a small local market), but they should work on a faster cashing out system. I’ve been there 3 times this past week, and each time, it has taken several minutes to get the cashier machine to work for my credit card
Aside from that, I will certainly continue to make weekly stop-​ins to just experience the atmosphere, see what’s cooking and maybe grab a few produce for my place.

Oh, how I love this little market. It’s like they read my mind and picked out all my favorite things! Best thing? JENI’S!!! Yes, I walk in in the dead of winter and they have my all time favorite, Grapefruit Frozen Yogurt. I couldn’t even get it at their retail store in Chagrin, but there it was! To die for — if you’re a fan of the sweet/​bitter taste of grapefruit you’ll be amazed.
They carry Lotte Sac Sac — a great asian fruit drink with pieces of mandarin orange in it. Their soups and salads are always incredibly good, and the sandwich they made me was delicious. Warm, friendly people, a jewel to be found no where else.

This is a neat little grocery store. I love the convience of it and the uniqueness of some of the products it offers– Vosges Haut Chocolate and Jeni’s Ice Cream!!! Like Kaitlin D suggests, it will lead to Queen City Cayenne heaven– spicy sweet fire on my ice cream palate waiting to be quenched with each spoonful of Queen City Cayenne. (I could write a poem its that good haha)
Additionally, they have lovely meals made to go– made to order on the spot. I will admit it took a little while (15 – 20 mins) to get all the meals ready to go. I was done shopping before they were even ready.
The groceries are slightly pricey and the selection is slightly slim (its the size a medium convience store). They have good prime rib salad (it was a little rare for my liking though) and delicious zucchini pancakes! Everyone tells me to go and try their sandwiches, which are suppose to be the best

I really like this little market. The décor is welcoming and the variety of products is pretty pleasing as well. Considering it’s a market, I don’t expect much more stock. Also, JENI’S, as Habby mentioned, is stocked here, which was THRILLING because I had been wanting to try the Queen City Cayenne for at least a year. There was no question about it, I had to try it when I found it here and am slowly working my way through the flavors.
I’ve only had their hot food once, which was on St. Patrick’s Day – the reuben was delicious, though a bit pricey, but for something other than pasta or pizza here, I was willing to pay the money.
We met the owner when we came in the first week they opened and he was a fantastic man. Very friendly and easy to talk to – that really makes me want to support his business.

One word… Jeni’s…
…ice cream that is.
There’s a whole cooler devoted to the stuff. Around twenty flavors. The most flavors offered in a retail store in NE Ohio and quite possibly all of Ohio. No more mail order, folks. Get your Jeni’s fix HERE. I will be going broke from this place.
So I stopped in for some lunch. Got the Fish Tacos. Was the iffiest thing on the menu. FISH TACOS IN LITTLE ITALY?! I figured why not. Well, I was pleasantly surprised. They were GREAT. Complete with red cabbage, chipotle cream and sides of homemade salsa, guac and chips. I opted for the mahi-​mahi. They also offer salmon.
The place itself is really cool, very old school. The guy behind the counter even donned an apron and a bow tie. I felt like I was back in time. Nice touch.
They offer just about everything you could want including imports and specialty items. There’s not a huge selection of any particular thing, but they have good options. Everything from cheese to deli meats to prepared foods and cleaning supplies. They have a nice selection of fruits and veggies too. It will be interesting to see how things turn over.
Considering they opened in the dead of winter, it looks like they are off to a good start. I look forward to walking up for lunch when it gets warmer. They have enough room for some potential outside seating.
You can keep up with their daily specials and new items on Facebook.
I wish them the best of luck!