Teresa’s Pizza

It’s hit or miss here. If it’s a good day, the pizza is great and if it’s a bad day, the pizza is just edible. This location does not allow you to order online which is definitely a negative but is worse because you have to repeat yourself multiple times when ordering by phone.

I love love love love their pizza. Although it is greasy, I mean come on it is pizza. The sauce is house-​made and original, the cheese is thick and yummy. It usually arrives nice and hot, so when you take a bite, the cheese may fall completely off, but I’m a huge fan. I love it wayyy better than papa johns sweet pizza.
Always had fast delivery, but the downside is at this location, they tend to burn the bottom of the chocolate chip cookies and still send them. (MAKE SURE THEY KNOW YOU WILL SEND IT BACK!!) Also, old woman on the phone is pretty slow at taking orders and the other girl doesn’t listen very well. I had ordered the rigatoni and meatballs but she didn’t give me the meatballs. YUCK!
Besides the pizza, they have great dinners. You can get rigatoni w/​meatballs, salad, and garlic bread. I love their italian house dressing although not everyone would like it because it is a lot different than the traditional kind. Just make sure to shake it up lol. You can also get chicken parm, sandwiches and fries, and a variety of other things.
If your not a fan of the pizza, maybe you will be a fan of the dinners because they are off the hook!
ENJOY!

Greasy, greasy pizza. The crust was good — nice and yeasty — but we needed to blot the slices to keep the grease from streaming down our arms. My kids decided to pass because they’d take a bite and the cheese would just slide completely off.
The house salad was iceberg lettuce, black olives, green olives, banana peppers and some cheese. Pizza night is never a nutritional win, but that is a sorry excuse for a salad.
Delivery was quick, so maybe we’ll try again — but something different.

Delicious! The food is reasonably priced, and the delivery is reasonably fast. The white pizza is cheesy just the right amount of oil and garlic. We also got a chef salad which was very good. I couldn’t be happier to have a great alternative to the pizza chains!

We’ve eaten at the downtown location and had great chicken parm. However, we ordered pizza delivery and when we got it, the cheese and mushrooms were all slopped to the side of the box. Terribly messy. Wings were decent but very very hot. Wouldn’t order pizza from them again. Crust was so hard and pizza had too much cinnamon. It was ok but not for $ 17 for a pizza.

I really didn’t care for this pizza. I found it rather bland. I’m embarrassed to say that I actually had to add a little bit of salt just to give some flavor! The crust isn’t too greasy, and the cheese was plentiful, but is was kinda just blah.

This place has an average of three and a half stars? Really? We ordered a veggie pizza the other night and it was pretty dreadful — soggy, bland and way overloaded with black olives. The side salads were fresh enough, but the «house» Italian dressing lacked character. The delivery guy was friendly, and our orders arrived quickly, so I’m giving Teresa’s an extra star. Woohoo.

Best pizza in the area by far! I love this place and eat here a couple times a month. Their sauce is home made and they are always generous with the cheese. Peperonis are always under the cheese which helps seal in the flavor.
The prices aren’t cheap, but keep an eye out for coupons. This is a pick up only location, so there is nowhere to sit down.

I have traveled throughout the states looking for a great pizza pie, with a succulent sauce to die for, and I have founded it! Theresa’s Pizza is by far the best pizza I have ever experienced thus far. I have been to a few locations and all were surperb, however this establishment besides the downtown Cleveland, Ohio location does not provide seating and are strickly pick up locations.
Never judge a book by it’s cover because this pizza rains supreme. always fresh toppings and always hot and cheesy!
I usually order the pizza with pep and sauage. also bbq wings are tasty.

Yuck! The pizza here is disgusting. I paid $ 13 for a cheese pizza that I wanted to throw out.
Also, the woman who took my order gave me a dirty look. My personality may not be great, but it’s not as disgusting as their pizza. Customer service might have earned them a second star.
This place is to be avoided.