All Fed Up

What’s not to love? Great food great people, great show next door to wander through. The Italian panini and homemade mac salad are only two of my recommendations. Burgers keep me coming back for um #4, no #7, nah #10, hm guess it depends on my taste buds that day. It’s a rare occasion when I don’t find something next door at All Mixed Up from unique wall hangings to my 100% America made (NYC) wool pea coat! If you haven’t been you need to go. See ya there!

Food is actually very good and I understand how a small business works. I understand the hours are not going to be the same as a chain place. I would gladly shop small but seriously who closes at 3 pm on a Wednesday when you are closed Sunday and half day saturday. As I write this review at 430 on a Wednesday in your parking lot, I have watched no less then 10 people attempt to open your door. Wish I was bring home a plethora of your sandwiches but I guess I will settle for Wegmans tonight.

Consistently good food. Consistent quality food.
AFU has a hearty menu that is sure to curb whatever food craving you may encounter.
AFU puts itself above just being any old sub shop or deli and the creative menu proves it. The Loaded Turkey sandwich is Thanksgiving between 2 slices of bread! The #6 burger, with a fried egg, onion rings, and BBQ sauce is like having breakfast, lunch, and dinner all at once. The Let’s Go Buffalo Chicken Tenders were great but I choked on them before I finished! BAM! Just kidding.
Clean and oddly mixed décor will only spurn your curiosity to venture next door to check out AFU’s mother store All Mixed Up. The dinning rooms style is a light hearted, tongue in cheek recycling of retro 60’s and 70’s tables keeps the experience fun.
Staff always friendly and always willing to go above and beyond to prove their passion and appreciation to their customers.

My wife and I enjoyed our time here. Everything was fresh and homemade. Prices were very reasonable and the staff was delightful to be around.

Tried All Fed Up for the first time today for lunch. I have driven by it for years and heard nothing but great things. Not sure why it took me so long. The food and service was outstanding. I had the special of the day, fish tacos, and it was simply delicious! The fish and vegges were so fresh and tasty. My daughter had the Buffalo Chicken Wrap, it too was just great and packed full of crispy chicken. Can’t wait to go back and try something else. Highly recommended!

This place deserves all the positive reviews. Simple but different sandwich offerings that are delicious. The place has a vintage feel to it and the people that run it are very nice.

Cute little café. My reuben was really good but needed just a little more sauce for my taste. The onion rings were perfect!

I’ve heard about this little place so many times and never stopped in until now and oh my how I’ve missed out. I came with the intention of getting a Reuben, but after talking to the owner he was telling me their pastrami was excellent and he had a special going on with it so I swapped my corned beef for the pastrami and it was superb, honestly some of the best pastrami I’ve ever had. The whole staff was super friendly. And they embraced the fact we had never been and gave us some take out menus to peek at. After ordering, my Reuben, my friends burger and our mozz sticks came out in no more than 7 minutes with my girlfriends cordon blue wrap to follow shortly after. Anyone looking for a quick lunch or a delicious savory couple date I would absolutely recommend here. 5 stars for sure.

Best little sandwich shop! Friendly and welcoming immediately! Then they found out we had never been there before and were new in the area… And they really made us feel welcome. They gave us a few samples of the favorites… So good!
Best Reuben sandwich, awesome daily soups, amazing cookie for dessert!
Adorable seating area! Retro & fun!
We want to be regulars!

So I’ve been hearing a lot about this place. Kept meaning to try it and am usually too far away, but I’ve made two trips now and plan on going back again.
Place is a tad difficult to find if you don’t know what you’re looking for. It’s connected to two other little stores, one their sister store, All Mixed Up, pretty far down Rt 11. Couple parking spots in the front, but more on the side.
The inside is nice. They’re clearly going for a 50s diner style look. There’s a ton of signs and trinkets everywhere, so its a tad cluttered. Parking signs, tons of signs with quotes on them. Looks like they pretty much did their décor shopping in the home section of Marshalls.
Very nice employees. Decent sized menu with some interesting choices mixed with old favorites. Their website does not work… don’t bother going to it to look for a menu. I told the owner their website doesn’t work, and he told me, in his own words, that he wasn’t concerned about it. Let’s just say he has some strong opinions on technology.
First trip, I ordered a buffalo chicken wrap. I always try buffalo anything at restaurants. It was good, decently spicy sauce on the chicken, wrap was made well. Second time, I tried a southwestern turkey wrap. Also good, though their Chipotle sauce could use a little more spiciness and kick to it. Both times I got fries as a side, and they have great fries. Cooked and seasoned perfectly.
Overall, I give it three stars because I wasn’t exactly blown away by the food. Their foods good, and I plan on going back to try other, more interesting things, so my rating may change, but after two visits, I haven’t yet had something that was so good that it makes me wanna make the long drive out again.

Nice place with good food and super friendly people. We had burgers, fries and soup and all of it was tasty!

This sandwich shop gets a tremendous amount of love from my fellow Unilocalers and deservedly so. I have read all the reviews and have desired to try this place but, they are open Monday thru Saturday until 6 or 7 PM which does not let me arrive before they close after leaving work. Sunday hours would be a nice addition and I had the chance to discuss this possibility with a person I believe was the owner.
Approaching from the outside, All Fed Up is in a very small strip mall on the Northbound side of Rt 11 in Cicero. Great signage is not abundantly present so, you might easily pass it by. When I found the location, I parked and entered the business. Where one enters leads directly to the counter where you place your order. Service was very pleasant and helpful. You then go to the dining area to the right side of the building. Since this business appears to be associated with another business in the strip mall, All Mixed Up (a «smoke» shop), there is no separation of the two at the entrance. As a result, when I entered All Fed Up, I could smell the unpleasant smokey note of incense. I despise that odor when I want to eat. Fortunately, my ordering process was swift and pleasant which allowed me to go to the separate dining area and avoid the continuance of the annoying smell (this is the reason for reducing the review to 4 stars)
The dining area has about 10 tables in a very clean and well kept room which is furnished with a variety of retro formica topped tables and decorated with paintings and posters meant to evoke an atmosphere from the 50’s and 60’s. Look at the pictures and decide for yourself but, I am neutral on the environment.
My food was brought out after a surprisingly brief wait. I thought how could they prepare anything of value with taste so quickly… well, I was about to get my socks blown off. I ordered a reuben with fries which gives any business plenty of room to screw up. All Fed Up delivered a very neatly and properly prepared sandwich with very attractive looking fries and pickle slices. Beyond looks, the sandwich was prepared with the meat and all ingredients spanning across the full width of the bread. Since this was a grilled sandwich, some places might put some butter in the center of the pieces of bread. Not here, proper attention to detail caused them to butter the bread edge to edge and grill it perfectly. The marble rye was tasty. The sandwich ingredients were all hot and fresh. Even though they did not serve hand sliced corned beef, this sandwich had very good quality meat which was hot and flavorful. I really enjoyed this wonderful sandwich.
French fries are often an afterthought, however, these were much more than an afterthought: fresh cut, golden brown, crisp exterior with a firm yet gentle interior and topped with either Kosher or Sea salt caused me to crave more. These were an exquisite indulgence.
This is a 4 star surprise in a strip mall that you should not miss.

Let’s be honest. It’s a sandwich joint. But it’s probably the best around.
After a few visits I can say the food is great, especially for the price.
I have to admit the service confused me. After you order, just go sit down in the dining room, and they will bring your food out to you.
Staff has been great and conversational. Definitely will return!

Brought the kids by for lunch based on the overwhelmingly positive reviews, and was not disappointed! My philly cheese steak and bowl of chicken & rice Mexican soup was delicious. My youngest devoured the grilled cheese and tomato soup that was on special. The teenaged burger connoisseurs ordered bacon cheeseburgers with fries and loved them. I’m sure we’ll be back any time we’re anywhere nearby.

Just picked up (and inhaled) take out from this great find in the greater Syracuse area! Service here was fantastic– very friendly people and my food was ready in no time. I got the island shrimp– the sauce with it was delicious (a great blend of spicy and sweet) and also the loaded turkey panini, and I must say that broccoli on it was a great touch! If you’re looking for an awesome place to grab a soup/​salad/​sandwich, this local place will not disappoint! I will certainly be returning the next time I’m in town.

Amazing amazing amazing … Everything was full of flavor … Customer service beyond perfection and ahhhh just perfect!!! we were driving back from Canada and stopped by this wonderful place it’s a true gem

Great little sandwich shop. Nice, funky, 50s style décor. Fast friendly service. I especially enjoyed the monte cristo

Great locally owned sandwich shop with a lot more! The Reuben was awesome. No skimping with the meat or flavor. The other guy had homemade chili and the tuna melt special and he loved them too. Definitely worth the short trek from the airport.

We decided to eat dinner here after reading the great reviews on Unilocal,and it certainly didn’t disappoint! I had the turkey sandwich with chicken noodle veggie soup, while my husband had the spicy steak. All of the food was great! In fact, the spicy steak was my favorite. The restaurant was clean, and the staff were really friendly and outgoing! I love that the ingredients are local, and it’s not a chain place. Prices were more than reasonable, and the décor was super fun. We will definitely be returning!!!

Great spot in Cicero. The Reuben was really good. It was golden brown, not greasy, and had tender corn beef. The salad had fresh greens and the fries were yummy too.
The décor also makes this place. The walls are lined with unique artwork and the dinning room has an array of interesting tables and chairs.
A little headshop that features shoes, crafts, and other odds and ends is connected to the restaurant.