Stopped in for a few pies since the wife is a big fan — really nice folks running the place, we shared an individual blueberry pie and a Reese’s cream pie. Didn’t get to try anything else on the menu, but what we had was very tasty.
Craig C.
Place rating: 3 San Jose, CA
Ordered a Cayucos omelette & a combo omelette. Way too much cheese on both of them and the Cayucos omelette was completely drenched in gravy.
Zach D.
Place rating: 5 Sacramento, CA
I loved everything about this place. The meat pie and chicken pot pie are delicious. The owner is very polite and a nice man to speak to as he’s always interacting with customers. He sells out daily, so best to come early. We only have been once, but I would love to go back and try the other items on the menu Great work!
Robert W.
Place rating: 4 Lompoc, CA
We had the chicken pot pie and the Shepherd’s pie. Both were flavorful and the crust was buttery and flaky. We’re definately coming back.
Billion L.
Place rating: 5 Cayucos, CA
Your supper tall employee Ryder is one of the coolest most hard working Young man I seen helping atleast 13 people at once with no one there. Good job Ryder! :) PS come work for me hahah
Diane v.
Place rating: 5 Mountain View, CA
We had a couple of great sandwiches there — my husband had the french beef and cheese sandwich and I ordered a grilled ham and cheese — which was a custom order. Really good sandwiches and the bread was excellent. I liked that no one batted an eye when i asked for my high maintenance order. The soup was good and the kid who put the sandwiches together was an excellent server/cook. I give this place 5 stars because for a sandwich place it was excellent.
Kat A.
Place rating: 4 Atascadero, CA
Our first time in, the guy, Kevin at the counter was super nice and helpful. The world needs more people like him. The mister ordered a cayucos burger and I got the mushroom burger. I also opted to try the macaroni salad(I’m super picky about this) and there are VERY few places that I like. It could have used a smidge more mayo, but was very good overall. Not that reesers crap! The burgers were very good, nice meat to bun to condiment ratio. Very well put together. Perhaps next time we will try some of their other offerings. Very good local kine joint. :)
Steve C.
Place rating: 5 Long Beach, CA
Great sandwiches. Boars Head meats, really fresh bread and nice people behind the counter.
Jon H.
Place rating: 4 San Jose, CA
Awesome customer service! They were so helpful and took our order with patience and great help with so many questions. The banana cream pie was delicious and a huge slice! The cinnamon bun was just ok and lacked the full flavor that you get with a great cinnamon bun at Old West Cinnamon Rolls in Pismo. Overall, definitely check this place out when in Cayucos!
Jenny H.
Place rating: 4 San Jose, CA
My family is pretty picky about our pies– and these are good! Had the banana cream pie. They serve large slices or individual pies. Husband had the cinnamon roll. The cinnamon roll was tasty but not anything too special. The pie was delicious. Crust was flaky and perfect. Could have had more banana flavor in the custard, but it was certainly delicious all around! The Service was super friendly– overall a great place to stop in after walking around town.
Mayra Z.
Place rating: 5 Los Angeles, CA
In this sleepy beach town, this place opens at 6am. The man taking our order was very nice, he could tell we were tourists and was patient with us. The omelets they serve are big and delicious. This place makes their own white and wheat bread which made for perfect toast. Better yet, free coffee! We walked here from our hotel.
Jesse L.
Place rating: 5 Los Angeles, CA
So Great can’t wait to go back People as so nice and the food is amazing
Tracy A.
Place rating: 5 Victorville, CA
My favorite spot in town! Everything is delicious from the German beer rocks to the pies. You can’t go wrong with anything they sell. The staff is super friendly. Everything sells out quickly so get there early. They’ll even set it aside if you want to take something home or with you for the road.
Deirdre M.
Place rating: 5 Orangevale, CA
Fruit, cheese & cream pie oh my. Deliciousness the teenagers say… Salad is just grand. The ground beef cabbage bun thrilled the boy/man. Special today open faced hot beef sandwich for $ 8.99. 1 block from beach Smiling happy workers
Joe P.
Place rating: 4 Chico, CA
Bomb breakfast burritos! Country burrito with gravy. Local place, owner is cooking! This is a small town, if you stop you need to get something to eat at this bakery/restaurant.
Sonya B.
Place rating: 4 Redwood City, CA
The pies – sweet or savory – are not to be missed and 5-star! The coconut cream pie and shepherd’s pie are personal favorites.(Even my Dublin born and raised friend declares the shepherd’s pie is 5-star.) The overall atmosphere of this place is what it is, a deli, so depending on the time of day and the crowd, the overall experience can change, which is why I prefer to take my pies to-go. The deli meats are Boar’s Head, my preferred brand since childhood so that too is 5-star but best enjoyed elsewhere.
Daniel L.
Place rating: 1 Westminster, CA
While I waited for my drinks to be made at Top Dog next door, I came over here for something to eat(Top Dog was a bit pricey for my liking). There were two men standing behind the counter yakking away and socializing with a female customer. I stood there for a couple of minutes, and after receiving no acknowledgement from either guy I simply left. Come on, really? Between two guys, you couldn’t take 2 seconds to greet a customer and say something like, «Hi, I’ll be right with you»? I mean, I didn’t expect a red carpet rolled out for me with flower bearers dropping rose petals ahead of me as I walked, like in «Coming to America» but no one likes to feel ignored — neither of you even looked at me, for fuck’s sake. I won’t be back.
Trisha B.
Place rating: 5 Huntington Beach, CA
YUMMY!!! Pros: Best Philly Cheesesteak ever! Awesome French Dip! Great Sandwiches in general!!! Service is super friendly and accommodating. Great selection of yummy pies! Decent parking. Cons: Closes too early.(6:00) Limited dine-in seating. Bottom line: Subway ain’t got nothin’ on the Pie Man! Come here. Eat here.
Alani M.
Place rating: 5 Cerritos, CA
Just happened to walk into this prize spot. Their beef pot pie was very good especially with the jalepeno hot sauce! The lady was very helpful and sweet, she recommended the side of homemade potato salad for a dollar. That was good too. Definitely was to try their dessert pies next time. Enjoy(;
Mark-john C.
Place rating: 5 Clovis, CA
Once again a great treat to visit Bob and Jeff at our favorite stop. If you want the best pot pies, berry pies and just food in general stop here and enjoy. Tell Bob and Jeff Mark from Fresno sent you.