Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza

The bottom of the pizza was completely burnt black, but unfortunately I didn’t realize it until I got home. I did not enjoy the pizza for this reason. I did like the curbside service though.

I don’t know why I never ate here before, passed it all the time. But glad I finally tried it. I was surprised to find that this was actually a chain, but the pizza here really is very good, I would say better than grimaldi’s. We had the classic pie and added prosciutto and mushrooms. Outstanding crust and really great flavor to the mushrooms, not the usual bland gray canned stuff you get. The pizza has that great brick oven char to it, if you don’t enjoy that, well, then you A) won’t enjoy the pizza here, and B) probably don’t really know what a real pizza is supposed to taste like.
We also had the meatballs, which come in a nice red sauce with some ricotta and focaccia wedges. Very good. I also tried their oven roasted wings, which I recommend. They are basically seasoned wings which are roasted in a coal oven and topped with caramelized onions. Very different from the wings most of us are used to, no heavy sauces and not fried. Despite this however they were very tasty and had a nice crust from their super hot oven. I could be wrong, but I would think these wings are fairly healthy too, they weren’t greasy at all and I didn’t pick up any added sugar or anything like that.
I would definitely come back, in fact I plan on it. Curious about their oven roasted ribs.

Tasty and fresh brick oven pizza. Consistently good food. Basic menu pizza, salads, a few entrees and wings. The traditional homemade Italian dressing dressing on the salad reminds me of homemade. Fresh food and cold craft beers. Wednesday is meatball and martinis. Daily drink happy hour specials. $ 4 local craft beers, brews are on point!!! Enjoyed the local Great South Bay Blonde Ambition brew, it was very flowery and fragrant, a surprisingly different favor.

Pizza was good, staff pleasant and prompt.
The meatball sandwiche was dam awful, tasteless.
Stay clear of the meatballs. Expensive for the price it should have blown me away.

I love everything about Anthony’s Pizza. The flat bread is crunchy and any of the flavor styles are delicious.
This location got 3 stars because we sat at the bar and the bartender (I think her name was Taylor?) was awful. She had a long face on like she was upset we sat at the bar. She made a face when I ordered water. She never made any attempt to asking how things were or even responding to our «thank you remarks». She was a long face unhappy hag the entire time. She went to serve our pizza and never asked for our plates or anything like we were supposed to guess she was going to serve us. Super awkward. She even placed the pie on top of my water and decided to leave it there until I moved it and still no word from the girl. I apologized my water was in the way and still nothing!!! Terrible bartender.
There’s a bar tender! Thank god! She’s super sweet and nice.

Conveniently situated near the mall, but far enough away from the bustle of Ring Road, is Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza. They have a great selection of local craft beer, especially for a chain. Although they have Italian soul food, salads, and sandwiches on the menu, I have never strayed away from their pizza. The roasted cauliflower pizza is my go-​to, but the eggplant marino, and meatballs & ricotta are also delicious. The lunch portion is very generous, plenty of food for dinner. Disclaimer: they like their pizza «well done,» which means it’s occasionally borderline burnt. I have been to Anthony’s a dozen times and have never gotten a burnt crust; it’s always had the right amount of char. If you’re going with a group at a popular time, be prepared to wait. It gets very busy at peak hours!

Anthony’s is one of those pizza places that is consistently good. I’ve been to a few locations and you really can’t go wrong. My most recent visit they had $ 4 Blue Point Mosaic IPA drafts and I ordered a lunch size (personal size) pepperoni pizza. All pizzas are great — I’ve had the traditional, meatball & ricotta, Philly cheesesteak, and several bites of my fiancé’s when she ordered the roasted cauliflower. All are yummy. They have a special coal-​fired wing recipe with caramelized onions which is delicious as well — very different from your traditional wing, but in a great way. If you’re looking for a good place for a pizza, you can’t go wrong with Anthony’s.

Just went the other day and wasn’t wowed by anything. Service was slow as it took us a while to be seated and the waiter was a type in which I felt when we asked a question it was a bother to our waiter. I was with some pretty bland people so we only ordered the margarita pizza and the meatball, both were fine… But nothing great.

Well I could not wait to come to this restaurant. We were seated right away. Our server was Taylor D the menu was scant as was Taylor ‘s service to the table.
when our food finally arrived no additional napkins were left and we didn’t see Taylor until she brought the check. very surprised. will not return to this restaurant as for the food, it tasted good but it was slightly burnt.

Beautiful restaurant. Is like a fancy pizzeria. The price was just right. The waitresses were fast and attentive. Even tho is a pizzeria I was expecting some pasta option but didn’t see any in the menu. The small calzone was huge and enough for 2. On my next visit I want to bring my kids and get the large calzone!

Great pizza for what I order. I’m not a regular pizza person so I’m not sure how theirs is. I recommend the roasted cauliflower pizza first (if you don’t like garlic I wouldn’t get it). Next the Paul and young Ron with sweet peppers. I also like their wings-​plain but tasty. i love the caramelized onions. I also had some kind of chicken sandwich with arugula during lunch that was really good too. I’ve always had very attentive service but this place can get really busy sometimes.

Give 4 for overall experience. But I’d drop it a star for the fact they have celery in their salad! Gross!
Mom and I came in for lunch, luckily we beat the crowd that comes in around 12. And were promptly seated. Our server was quite friendly and attentive. She came over to check on us once we had our Food and to make sure my water glass was full.
We got a family salad with Gorgonzola. And it was quite big. No wonder it’s called a family salad! The two of us couldn’t finish it. Especially since we also shared an order of 2 meatballs. And oh my those were yummy meatballs! And I loved the foccacia bread that came with it.
Mom and I would come here again no problem. :) And I’m totally interested in getting a pot of meatballs to enjoy at home some time.

Didn’t meet my expectations. My small group of three ordered an Eggplant Marino and it was a fumble. Crust was pita bread like and far from the typical New York pie. Pizza had no cheese on it and didn’t mention that fact on the menu. Sauce, eggplant and a little basil on that lousy crust. This is not my type of pizza. Added a star for the servers. Ragazze Carine.

Really impressed. Great food, ambiance and service.
Music playing and tvs have football games on.
Will be back for sure.

If I could give Anthony’s 100 stars I would. Absolutely everything on the menu is amazing. the food is so good, I eat like I’m eating for 3 people.
The pizza is top notch, I’ve had them all! So delicious! The chicken wings are also delicious. If I could eat here every single day I would.
The prices are decent. I don’t mind paying for the awesome food here.
The service is also great, so far that I’ve experienced. I plan on taking out food here and making it a weekly thing!
Overall, super highly recommended !

This was some damn good pizza– that, or we just made a really good combo (prosciutto + caramelized onions on a «create your own» large pizza). It tasted better than it looked in my opinion (prosciutto was kinda just thrown on there but who cares if it tastes great?). The onions were flavorful and crunchy, and prosciutto added even more flavor. The crust and dough were cooked crispy just how I like it. A large pie was way too much for 2 of us, but that’s ok if you’re okay with leftovers! (Who wouldn’t be???). I wasn’t sold on some of their pre-​made pie choices thus why we made our own– if I come back, I’ll probably make my own again.
They have curbside pickup and take out which is nice– I think they’d do even better with a quick casual section for people that want to have a quick slice rather than do waiter service.
I went here around 4pm on a Saturday which is an odd in between hour between lunch and dinner and it was PACKED– can only imagine how crowded it gets around 12pm or 6/​7pm.

Coal fired pizza? Sign me up!
Anthonys is pretty darn good! Crispy thin crust, yummy tomato sauce, cheesy yumminess!
What’s up with the appetizer menu? No calamari? boooooooo
Pizza is well done… like some parts of the crust is black. We had sausage, fresh mozzarella, and prosciutto… YUMMMM!
They have a full bar, drinks are okay.
Single person restrooms… always clean, neat, and smelling fabulous!
Parking is great, they are in a complex.
Service is okay, young girls trying there best! We are always seated right away, even when its packed, they manage to get everyone seated pretty quickly.

I’ve been here a couple of times and always found everything pretty good.
They are located in a mini shopping complex, so there is plenty of free parking…
The place is pretty big inside, with lots of tables, a large bar, and about eight big screen TVs mounted throughout the restaurant. They have two private restrooms, one for the women and one for the men, so I can imagine a wait when they are packed (I never been there when they were super busy).
I’ve always order there brick oven pizza, which is cooked well done (just the way I like it). It always seems fresh and is really good, although I have had better elsewhere… I won’t mention names…
They also offer curbside pick up, which I see lots of people utilizing…
The staff is pretty good, just not as attentive as I would like, I found myself having to get there attention a few times when I needed something. Also, they have a well stocked bar, but it is lacking in specialty liquors…
Overall, I like this place and would recommend it to other…
Happy Unilocaling :)

3.5÷5 for me here
We like to come to Anthony’s when we are looking for a lively atmosphere and good food. Here, you can expect to find decent waits as the place unfortunately does not take reservations. There are plenty of TVs playing any game of choice which allows for a good night out during a sporting event.
Getting to the food, the menu is very small and simple which is sometimes better. We always like to start with the wings that are served with sauteed onions on focaccia bread that are pretty good. We have done an assortment of calzones that are ok and pizzas that are also good. Overall, we have never had a problem with the main things they are good at.
The wait staff is friendly and attentive and the prices are reasonable so this is perfect for a group outing.
Buon appetito.

Lunch or Dinner you cant go wrong here. By no means fine dining but was never disappointed. Crazy as it sounds, the Tuna Salad on the Lunch menu is Great.
Dinner, Pizza and Wine, cant beat it.