Sherri’s Cookies

Capitola, United States

4.2

Closed now

20 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 831-475-8335
Website:
www.sherriscookies.com
Address:
1855 41st Ave, Capitola, CA, 95010
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
630 ftCapitola Mall
0.2 mi41st northbound
0.2 mi41st & Capitola northbound
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Delivery
No
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Bike Parking
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes

Today

Today 9:00 am – 8:00 pm
Closed now
Local time (Capitola) 20:41 Saturday, 31 May 2025

Business hours

Monday 9:00 am – 9:00 pm
Tuesday 9:00 am – 9:00 pm
Wednesday 9:00 am – 9:00 pm
Thursday 9:00 am – 9:00 pm
Friday 9:00 am – 9:00 pm
Saturday 9:00 am – 8:00 pm
Sunday 9:00 am – 7:00 pm

Description

Specialties

14 Delicious Kinds of Cookies! We also offer Marianne’s Ice Cream (17 Flavors Min), Muffins, Churros, Cinnamon Twist, Pecan Pies, Brownies, Cup Cakes, Coffee (Santa Cruz Coffee Roasting), Smoothies, Macaroons and A Lot more. Your approval of our quality is guaranteed!

History

Established in 1978.

Sherri’s Cookies has been serving the best homemade cookies and brownies in the beautiful beach town of Santa Cruz since 1998. We started with a simple dream: to be sweet to everyone. With that dream, and a love and passion for baking, Sherri’s Cookies continues serving the premium quality baked goods that are sure to please even the most discriminating. We are enthusiastic about all of our products. Our cookies keeps filling the air with the tantalizing aroma of fresh-​out-​of-​the-​oven treats.

Meet the Business Owner

Sherri N.

Business Owner

Sherri is not only the top notch pastry expert but also one of the finest people you will ever get to know. One would wonder how she got interested in this field having Graduated in Child pshycology. But wait!

Child pshychology and cookies sound a little familiar after all maybe she knows what she is doing.

Related places

You might also like:
1
mi
The Ugly Mug
4640 Soquel Dr
1
mi
Gayle’s Bakery & Rosticceria
Upper Village Shopping Ctr 504 Bay Ave
1
mi
Lucky
1475 41St Ave
1
mi
Just Cake
712 Capitola Ave
1
mi
Aldo’s Italian Bakery
4628 Soquel Dr
1
mi
Beckmann’s Old World Bakery
3555 Clares St Ste G

Nearby

Browse nearby places:
1
ft
Payless Shoesource
1855 41st Ave
1
ft
Journeys
1855 41st Avenue Suite D1
1
ft
Sports Fever
1855 41st Ave
1
ft
Pacific Sunwear of California
1855 41st Ave
1
ft
Steve’s Hallmark Shop
1855 41st Ave
1
ft
M@trix Santa Cruz
1855 41st Ave Ste F9

20 reviews of Sherri’s Cookies

No registration required
Place rating: 5
San Jose, CA
Seriously one of my favorite places to get cookies I love the little mini cookies. Every time I go to Capitola Mall its a must to stop and get some, and the staff is always wonderful.
Place rating: 5
Santa Cruz, CA
This has been my family’s favorite place to get cookies, it’s a tradition to get the mini chocolate chip cookies when we go to the mall they are by far my favorite in town !
Place rating: 5
Walnut Creek, CA
Best cookies in town! Hands down. I have been many times and always satisfied. I recommend this place.
Place rating: 5
Roseville, CA
Stop… Go no further… This is the best cookie, macaroon, yummy delight shop in Santa Cruz! The mini cookies are my favorite, macaroons are a close second! Not only are the treats amazing but the people are fantastic! This was my very first job and Jim and Sherri are gracious loving people!!! Make sure to stop by and grab a delicious treat!
Place rating: 5
Santa Cruz, CA
I love Sherri’s cookies! I can’t go to the mall without getting ½ a pound each of their snickerdoodles, chocolate chips, and white chocolate macadamia! Soooo yummy! I usually need more because I can finish those bags in 10 minutes and my friends always swarm them too. Their pastries are also pretty good, I especially like there chocolate covered strawberries (huge!) but their mini cookies are king! Addicted since 2005.
Place rating: 4
Santa Cruz, CA
Have always liked the cookies but also try the cheesecake, fruit parfaits, and Marianne’s ice cream. There’s more to this place than you think.
Place rating: 2
San Bernardino, CA
Ordered a strawberry smoothie. Just not impressed. Sour strawberries. I like them sweet. I’d go back to try their cookies or cheesecake though. Just not into the smoothie I had.
Place rating: 2
Campbell, CA
Not the best cookies I’ve had. There is nothing special about these. I got the M&M mini cookies.
They are ok for a craving but Mrs. Fields has the best cookies, but that’s all the way in San Jose so these will suffice. I probably won’t be back considering the price and taste.
Place rating: 2
Santa Monica, CA
Meh. Got a chocolate chip cookie and a sugar cookie with rainbow sprinkles. While edible I just didn’t enjoy them. Something’s just off with their dough. Prices per cookie are a bit high considering it’s not a big cookie. Won’t be back — I can make better at home off my Nestles recipe.
Place rating: 5
Lafayette, CA
The mini cookies are the best! Freshly baked and extra delicious! I always come here first before going anywhere else in the mall, and all the employees are extremely friendly. If you need your sweet tooth satisfied this is the place, thank you Sherri!
Place rating: 5
Alameda, CA
My mom used to get me a bag of minis each time we came to the mall (if I was good). They were always a little crisp, very buttery and chewy in the middle. I love these cookies. As I got older I would get the m &m, macadamia nut and the snickerdoodle and all were spectacular. I love sherris cookies. They’ve been in business a long time. They’re doing something right, obvies!
Place rating: 5
Scotts Valley, CA
I LOVE LOVE LOVE their chocolate chip cookies!
Place rating: 2
Santa Cruz, CA
I love sherries cookies there items are all such a treat. I am a mall employee and go to sherries 3 – 4 times a week.
However recently they decided to start charging for ice … I spend a lot of money every month here and I am very disappointed that they would start charging for ice. I mean really? Ice? Since this recent update I probably won’t go to Sherri’s anymore unfortunately. To charge for ice is just ridiculous.
Place rating: 5
Santa Cruz, CA
Amazing Cookies!
Sherri’s are some of the best cookies in town. Good deals and they use organic ingredients. M&M cookie and chocolate fudge cookie, mmm!
Place rating: 5
Watsonville, CA
ALWAYS come here and buy 3 to get the 4th free! THE BEST cookies in the mall! or in town even! Loyal customer for years! Its a daughter and Mommy tradition to always stop buy and buy some from Sherri’s… I also get the days old cookies and they’re still very good and soft and not old! Leaving a Unilocal to support them! Love!
Place rating: 2
Santa Cruz, CA
Two cookie places bookmarked, two have failed. I am now 0⁄2 which makes me utterly upset because I am going out of my way to spend and consume calories when I have a pantry full of baking ingredients at home and not just that, a taste of the kids’ cookies made me wish I opted for a package of Chips Ahoy (and I hate Chips Ahoy, too).
Now I understand why you cannot buy the mini cookies in singles. You need to buy a ½lb of it because if not, there will be a ton of it by the time they close up shop. The girl packed more than a half a pound but I agreed because mind you, I had 4 kids to look after. My daughter wanted the frosted snowman sugar cookie whilst I bought myself a brownie on a stick and a longhorn.
Cookies — crispy, didn’t taste fresh, very bland (like it was missing vanilla extract and sugar)
Brownies — nothing a box of Betty Crocker can’t do
Longhorn — dry, dry, and dry
I was excited to come here because I have been confined at home since Wednesday and because this was a bookmark. I am now terrified to buy cookies now.
Place rating: 4
Morgan Hill, CA
My husband brought me a cookie from Sherri’s today. Wow!
It was chocolate chip with walnuts — and it was actually encrusted with walnuts on top — FABULOUS! I was soft on the inside, a little crispy on the outside — just the right mix of chocolate and nuts. And, it was the perfect size.
Congrats, Sherri — you’ve got a devoted fan!
Place rating: 5
Elk Grove, CA
I was just walking around the mall and could smell the cookies… which naturally drew me closer. After much deliberation I chose the White Chocolate Macadamia Cookie. THE BEST COOKIE I have ever had! (Don’t tell my Mother or Grandmother!) :)
This is THE place to go for all your sweet tooth needs! You will not be disappoined! Also, the have Santa Cruz Coffee Roasting for their coffee (WAY better than Starbucks) AND they also have my all-​time favorite ice cream– Marriane’s!
LOVE IT LOVE IT LOVE IT.
Place rating: 5
Boston, MA
I have to say these are the best mall cookies I have ever tasted in my entire life. They’re crunchy on the outside but perfect and soft on the inside. You can buy the bigger cookies for about $ 1.25 and they also have small cookies too that you can buy in a bunch but I don’t remember how much it is. If you buy 3 cookies you get the 4th for free :)
The white chocoloate macadamian nut cookie is SO GOOD!!! My favorite.
Capitola mall isn’t that great BUT THIS PLACE MAKES IT WORTH IT TO GO
Place rating: 5
Sunnyvale, CA
These cookies are delish! Waaaaayyyyy better than anything I’ve ever had from a Starbucks treat shelf (which is located right by it, btw). My girlfriends and I tried the chocolate, the snickerdoodle, the oatmeal raisin and the m&m cookies and they were all great samples of their type of cookie. They tasted very fresh, soft on the inside and a lil crisp on the edges.
My personal favorite is the Oatmeal Raisin… yum yum!
The mini cookies are ¼lb for 2.75 and one large cookie is about 2 $ each. It’s totally worth it. I also noticed she offered smoothies, ice cream and slurpees but I didn’t try them.
Sherri’s Cookies is a lil aisle store in the Capitola Mall, btw.