Great Tim Hortons location! Nice size dining area, friendly counter service, delicious coffee with even more delicious doughnuts… where can you go wrong?! Tim Hortons Doughnuts(and coffee) beat the other leading brand by far. Not only are the doughnuts delicious & fresh but the variety of selections is amazing– leaving you indecisive! They also sell muffins, cookies, Timbits and other baked goods, even offer egg sandwiches. The actual dining area is clean and fresh. There’s a fireplace for that cozy corner while sipping your coffee. Parking is available. Just be careful because it’s located at a busy intersection & you can only go in one way. Great addition to Staten Island — can’t wait until we get some around Long Island!
Andy Y.
Place rating: 4 Staten Island, NY
24 hour spot to get a late night coffee and donuts with friends or just if your on the road! Parking: Small parking lot in the front fitting around 8 – 10 cars but a lot of parking on the side so you should be fine. Interior: Small but spacious enough because I have never seen this place super full where I cannot sit down even if your in a group. Plenty of single sits bar style on the edge and a comfy seat or two near the fireplace. Bring your friends and have one of those deep convos here at night time. Chocolate Nutella Hazelnut Donut: That name itself is mouth watering. Please indulge yourself in this donut if you love chocolate. Please see all the pics here on it and you will def get your own. Sorry I guess its a cheat day. Overall: Chill atmosphere. Good prices. Great donuts and great drinks. Definitely a spot to hit up on a chill day in Staten Island
Susan M.
Place rating: 5 Brooklyn, NY
I’ve had Tim Horton’s a bunch of times by have never physically come to the store. My friends dad would always go there and bring back different doughnuts from there. Recently when my friends and I were going up to PA we stopped there since I had to pick up Kcups for my friend. It comes off like a Dunkin doughnut type but a lot better! They have all different coffees and drinks. The drink that caught my eye was the Frozen hot chocolate with chocolate whip cream. I just had to get it and try it. I am a HUGE chocolate fan and it sure was amazing. It was so thick and good! My friend thought it was too sweet but I thought it was good. I also was a little hungry so I just got a grilled cheese sandwich. I was looking at the the menu and they had wraps with chicken and egg sandwiches but I just wanted something light and small. The bread on the grilled cheese was almost like a panini bread. It was nice and toasted and the cheese was nice and melted. Sometimes when you go to Dunkin they don’t toast there stuff right and you get cold cheese. To me that’s the worst because I HATE cold cheese! The also have so many different doughnuts and they have special ones too not just your regular doughnuts like at Dunkin. They have a Carmel chocolate, Nutella and a sugar cookie one. I have tried the Nutella one so many times and it is amazing. It is so soft and doughy and than has Nutella all over it and peanuts! What an amazing mix! I would defiantly come here again and I really wish we had one in Brooklyn!
Anthony C.
Place rating: 4 Staten Island, NY
Nice place for a quick coffee and donuts Donuts are better than DD Coffee too. Nutella donuts. Need not say anything more
Marlena K.
Place rating: 3 Brooklyn, NY
I stopped by Tim Hortons for the first time and I have to say its like a Dunkin Donuts on steroids! They have such a huge selection of donuts, the cool thing about it, is that they have some specialty donuts that are just really good, not to mention unique. The Nutella donut is amazing and the strawberry filled flower shaped donut was just as good. My suggestions definitely involve getting a donut, a box of donuts, all the donuts you can fill in your belly. The frozen hot chocolate is very chocolateyyyyy and a bit to sweet for my liking. I didn’t try anything else although they offer a large selection of sandwiches and other drinks as well as coffee. I suggest stopping by for a quick snack, definitely will return to stuff my face with more of their donuts! Best part they are open 24 hrs. yes that’s right 24 hours of donut indulgence!
Shirley D.
Place rating: 5 Staten Island, NY
The drive thru makes it very convenient to get food especially in the am when u you need that coffee in a hurry. The munchkins taste better n are more tastier than DD. the staff i great.
Ari S.
Place rating: 5 Staten Island, NY
Their bakery is much fresher and has more variety than any Dunkin Donuts on the island. Although I’m not big on donuts, every now and then I’ll have a coconut one and they’re great here. What I really like is their lemon poppy muffins. I haven’t tried one I haven’t liked, but that definitely stands as my favorite. Their coffee has always been fresh and their tea is good as well. I’ve had the hot chocolate once and while it was nothing special, it at least wasn’t watery or even greasy like at most other places. Generally, I don’t eat the food so other than the occasional muffin, I don’t have much to say. I drink black coffees and rarely iced, but once or twice I have gotten it with chocolate whipped cream as a little pick me up. This is the only place I know of that actually has chocolate whipped cream, so it’s nice to have the option. My friends all like their specialty drinks, although I’ve never tried them. There is a decent amount of parking. There is also a drive through, although it is pretty tight. They didn’t build the place though, so you can’t fault them for something that is out of their hands.
Rocco P.
Place rating: 4 Staten Island, NY
I live so close to here but I have always relied on my local Dunkin for my coffee and donut cravings. However, my first visit here did not disappoint! I got a cheese croissant which was super fresh, buttery, and perfectly flaky. I got a hot chocolate as well, but I don’t recommend it if you’re not into super sweet things; I wish I had gotten a latte instead which my mom tried and she loved it. I’m happy to say Tim Hortons will replace Dunkin for me for a while!
Jennifer B.
Place rating: 4 Brooklyn, NY
I just tried Tim Hortons for the first time yesterday, and I really have been missing out. The raspberry timbits were ridiculously amazing. They’re like Dunkin Donuts munchkins, but better. The nutella donut was really good, and they don’t skimp out on the nutella.
Gerard P.
Place rating: 4 Staten Island, NY
I haven’t sampled a wide fare from this particular location, but what I have eaten I’ve thoroughly enjoyed. You go to Tim Horton’s for 2 things: donuts and Timbits. I have never had a complaint about either. Plus, I had breakfast for the first time this past week, and I can tell you that they make a mean sausage biscuit. Better than McDonald’s, in fact. Contrary to the experiences of other reviewers, I actually think their customer service is relatively efficient and prompt, especially if you’re ordering via drive thru, which I would recommend. Overall, a satisfying experience.
Julie M.
Place rating: 5 Brighton Beach, Brooklyn, NY
Gosh I love this place. The Nutella donuts are to die for!!! The cheese croissants either plain or used for a sandwich is so good. The coffee is awesome! This place is like dunkin donuts but good. Also the apple fritter fresh is life altering!
Jeffrey S.
Place rating: 4 Fair Lawn, NJ
I have to tell ya, if Tim Horton’s was nearby I would hit them up pretty much all the time. If Starbucks had sex with Dunkin Donuts this would be their offspring. It takes the Dunkin Donuts formula to the next level with better coffee, donuts and sandwiches that never see the inside of a microwave. They are more of a café like setting and have a few comfy leather chairs and a fireplace. The feel is definitely more reminiscent of a DD but the quality and experience is on a whole other level. It’s my understanding that they are the #1 fast food chain in Canada and, having stopped by there yesterday on my way to a funeral, it’s easy to see why. It was actually surprised to see a DD a few hundred feet away because with TH so close I would never stop there. Oh, they also had a tray of free«Munchkins» or whatever their Canadian equivalents are called. Yummm.
Joseph M.
Place rating: 2 Manhattan, NY
This place opened to many pomps and celebrations, but definitely not for their taste. I went here to try it out after seeing so many people and students go here on their way to CSI for classes, so I decided to give it a try. The first time I went here, I ordered hot chocolate. It did not taste like hot chocolate at all, it was very watery and tasted like drinking water with cocoa powder. The next time I went, I got an iced coffee. The iced coffee had absolutely no taste of flavor at all, so at that point, I stopped coming here. It’s a shame because this place is brand new, very sleek and modern, with a killer fireplace, but the drinks don’t live up to the Tim Horton’s name. I prefer Dunkin Donuts over this any day, at least their drinks and coffees actually have flavor and you’re not just drinking watered down hot chocolate or iced coffee that tastes like sink water.
Nasha N.
Place rating: 2 Staten Island, NY
For some reason, this timmy is not the same like the ones in buffalo or canada. It is lacking something. But it is better than donut dunkins.
Hanane D.
Place rating: 2 Heartland Village, Staten Island, NY
I’m a big time coffee lover so I was excited and looking forward to finally trying Tim Hortons coffee. This new location in Staten Island, is a 24 hour location and has a drive-thru. The place is nice inside, it’s nicely decorated, neat and clean. Unfortunately, the coffee was not good. I ordered the salted caramel iced latte. It was terrible. So I immediately returned it and asked for a regular iced coffee, which didn’t taste good either. My friend ordered a hot chocolate. It was just alright. The donut display looked yummy. The food menu looked quite enticing. I may go back for lunch to try those out. However, I won’t be ordering coffee here!
Alexis A.
Place rating: 3 Staten Island, NY
Really good donuts, really fresh and tasty. As soon as you see them its like there own version of Christmas lights and just light up so beautiful ! Not crazy about the cappuccinos they make, the taste is kind of weird and not sure if its just the brand of coffee they use. 24 hour drive thru — LOVEIT! You can go inside and eat and hang out theres a lot of room to sit and also TVs. I go for the donuts only in my opinion and I love them! There so good! TRYATYOUROWNRISK! They can become addicting!
David J.
Place rating: 2 CORNWELLS HTS, PA
I went there last night on my home to phila from long island, Had a donut and a turkey garden club sandwich, it was suppose to come on a four cheese bagel, but they were out, they told me this after i paid, that didnt matter cause i got it on a jalepeno bagel which i would have prefered anyway. I asked for Mayo on the sandwich, but i got some honey mustard sauce instead. i didnt realize it as i didnt eat the sandwich till the next day for lunch(which is today). The sandwich was really good. but nothing spectacular. As for the donut, it looked amazin, it was just a chocolate frosted, but looked decadent. however the taste didnt live up to the look. it tasted like a normal dunkin donut. not impressed at all. when i go to Krispy Kreme and get a donut, after eating it I think«wow, that was awesome», i didnt get remotely close to that feeling from here. sorry. wont go out of my way to go here again.
Mark S.
Place rating: 2 Jersey City, NJ
As a confirmed caffeine junkie I have to be honest. Whenever new places open up there is always a mad rush to try it out. Tim Hortons included. I was excited to come and try this place out. It could have waited, though better than in Toronto a few years back still not worth rushing there. Pros– prime location on the corner of Victory Blvd & Richmond Ave, 24⁄7 drive thru and the muffins were ok and lots of staff to get your order done. Had the breakfast sandwich. Loved the cheesy biscuit. The wife got the bacon wrap which was palatable. Our combos were supposed to come with hash browns but there was a wait so we replaced it with a blueberry and red velvet muffin. Now the cons. We both ordered medium coffees. Definitely not a fan of their coffee, it seemed watered down to me. I could understand if it was iced but it was hot. There is lot of competition for coffee in the area. Maybe I will try again but I won’t go out of my way.
Abelle N.
Place rating: 1 New York, NY
I always get asked how’d my ass get so big… sighhh… Hey…yes…donuts are pretty unhealthy… By all means have one occasionally as a treat… but every day is not good for you… This place just opened a few months ago… They replaced dunkin donuts with Tim Hortons… really wished they didn’t do that… Donuts are over priced and mediocre… Place is clean… but …hey we will see how long that will last… {Popular Donuts } –honey cruller –Boston cream –chocolate dip –sour cream glazed Donuts are typically very high in sugar and saturated fat which is bad for your heart… Twenty four hour donut shop… huge parking lot… staff doesn’t understand English… so hard to communicate… pretty annoying… Lots of seatings… yes there is a restroom!
Mariya E.
Place rating: 3 Huguenot, Staten Island, NY
UPDATED: I did add a star since my last visit but like a previous reviewer said I do not like the inconsistency. The hot cocoa was HEAVENLY and doughnuts were SUPER soft in the middle which was a huge plus. I would also highly recommend french vanilla cappuccino. I feel like TIm Hortons is only really good and fresh in the morning, as the day progresses the quality regresses. ________________________________________________________________ I was so happy to hear that Tim Hortons was opening on Staten Island as I was a HUGE fan of it when I was in Canada! Needless to stay it cannot compare to any of my experiences in Canada but it is a step up from Dunkin Doughnuts. We did go through the drive-thru and this is a review of what I tried: Regular Small Coffee; Unfortunately the coffee was not good, it tasted to burnt. I would assume it was because we went in the late evening and the coffee wasn’t freshly brewed. Huge disappointment, also it wasn’t served in the holiday cups which was a bummer too since they are so darn cute. Timbits: SUPERSWEET but not in a good way, definitely not how it was in Canada… another bummer. Fruit Explosion Muffin: HEAVENLY! It tasted so fresh and a great texture, I really enjoyed it! Service: The girls who were working drive-thru where so friendly! It such a pleasant change from all the other coffee shops on Staten Island. They were all smiles and it kind off made up for the bad coffee… kind off. I will definitely come back in a few weeks and try it again, fingers crossed there will be an improvement.