Panoony’s Pizza and Wings

This place in the Hood of Brownsburg (overheard here) is awesome. Family owned the homade dough and marinara are a great combination.
The prices are very reasonable especially for the quality of the food usually found in higher end places.
The atmosphere is vary laid back and casual is not great for groups but are just fine for a casual lunch or dinner.
The best thing is the food and is highly recommended.

I had my reservations at first about this place since it was in the same building complex as a gas station. But you can’t judge a book by its cover.
I’m a pretty big stickler about pizza. Jockamo’s and Baxbeauz are my usual selections, but this place lured me in with a coupon for free breadsticks.
Ordered a BBQ chicken pizza and it was great! They certainly didn’t skimp on the BBQ or the chicken.
I will definitely be coming back.

Not very good, and the wings stink. I went here going off the reviews and comments, let me save you some time. Don’t order or go. Best part about it, ordered carry out and then walked in to the store to see all employees on there cell phone. Asked the person what’s up what are you doing and his comment was on Facebook sorry and then he makes a comment, «what no tip».

My friends and I have ordered Panoony’s a couple times, and they’re delicious! I’ve had the bacon chicken ranch and Hawaiian pizzas. Both are very good. The slices are gigantic. Out of all the pizza places in Indy, this is one of the best that delivers!
We’ve also gotten breadsticks. They come with a variety of dipping sauces you can choose from.
Every time I’ve called, the people have been very friendly. The delivery time is usually not too bad as well.

We finally have a favorite pizza spot! After passing this restaurant several times we finally decided to check it out based on how good the reviews were. We live in Avon and couldn’t find a really good place to get quality pizza until now! We ordered a calzone, pizza, wings and breadsticks (with spicy cheese) and all were phenomenal. The dough is like everyone says, soft and chewy! It can’t be beat! You can tell everything is made to order, fresh and prepared perfectly. On top of it being amazing food, the prices are great too! Thank you Papoony’s!

If you like a great pizza, this place is the place to get it from! We ordered the deluxe and it could hardly contain all the toppings. They make their dough fresh every day and all their ingredients are fresh and not frozen and you can tell with every bite. The breadsticks were hot, soft, chewy and delicious.
This place seems to be more set up for take-​out than eat-​in and have a few tables. When the food is this good I can easily overlook everything else, so this rating is just for the food.

We get a veggie pizza; half no cheese half extra cheese. They always get it right, the veggies are fresh and the crust is excellent!

Panoony’s is a great little place. The pizza is hard to beat and the customer service is top notch! Don’t let the location fool you!

Wow! As if humongous and delicious chicken wings weren’t enough the pile-​on pizza was fantastic. Drove 40 minutes to eat here in this «nowhere» pizza shop (located in a gas station strip mall, really? Lol) and it was worth every mile. There are 3 booths and a few 2-​person tables so I wouldn’t call it an eat-​in restaurant.
But I WOULD call it a must-​go pizza place on my shirt local list.

Never have actually ate in the restaurant, but awesome service and great food. One of the best pizza’s I’ve ever had. I order every Thursday for poker night and the new guys always wonder what that is. Well that is panoony’s. Eat it you will love it. Hell i just talked myself into calling them.

This is the best pizza place to order from if you are having a party. The giant pizza is a conversation starter and a good deal. Just make sure you order early! The wing everyone said were delicious. I don’t eat wings but these wings are giant! The salad was ok but not sure if I would order again.
We ordered for delivery and it came right on time. I was not aware you should order the big nooney ahead of time so they really made it work for us

This is our favorite pizza place since moving to brownsburg. We dont even thing about the regular pizza chains anymore. The service is great and the pizza is awesome.

A bit pricey but very good pizza. Clean and usually pretty quick. Had delivered once and guy was super nice. If you like trying different place I would give this one a chance.

Ordered for delivery and it came early. Medium sausage and pepperoni pizza, three meat calzone and a large order of breadsticks with cheese and pizza sauce.
Breadsticks are awesome. Plain but the texture is perfect, soft and chewy.
The cheese sauce was fine. Nothing to write home about but good.
The pizza sauce is too sweet alone or with breadsticks but when you get it on the calzone or pizza, it is delicious!
Pizza was good. Crumbly small town sausage and good pepperoni. Crust was soft and perfect.
The calzone was HUGE and stuffed with toppings. Great value! I ate two breadsticks and could not even get through half the calzone, and I have a big appetite.
The gentleman who took my order and the delivery driver were both great.
Overall, this place is awesome compared to its nearest competition and the boring chain places. Will definitely order again, excited to try other menu items.

Great pizza, good wings. Delivery drivers are always super nice and have change. Price is fair. Nice break from the big chain pizza. Eat in is small an simple take out or delivery is the way to go!

Get the big Noony. You can feed an army literally and it is great.

Great pizza, great breadsticks. Our major complaint was the paper plates, which gives the impression of a much less casual meal than we were expecting when we arrived. The other thing was probably nothing the employees could help on a Sunday evening, but I believe the air conditioner was broken on a hot day so the door was open, which invited gnats and flies. Even so, we will be back!

Fantastic quality pizza. The breadsticks are rather plain, but they do tell you this in the menu. I ordered a side by side large 2 topping pizza (which was a $ 12.99 summer special). On one side (my side) was bacon and ham, and on the other was pepperoni and pineapples (my dad’s). The sauce is different, but good.
They offer free delivery, but I haven’t tested this out yet. I will update this review when I have.
Their place is decorated with Beatles, Elvis, and I think I even saw a picture of John Lenin. I’m not really into those genres of music, but it did offer a homey feeling to the place.
The location often scares off some people. It’s located next to a gas station (Marathon) and some other store. It’s pretty empty most of the time, so I wouldn’t be too worried.
The cashiers and management were great. They made sure we were comfortable, provided plates, napkins, silverware, and gave us an extra table. The man who answered our questions was polite and checked on us regularly.
I’ll be ordering again, by delivery.

Ordered for delivery a large half cheese, half mushroom pizza, bread sticks with cheese sauce and a 2 liter coke. It came within 45 minutes which was expected with how late we ordered. First time ordering from here and it was decent pizza. Not a ton of flavor; lots of cheese and the dough was good but could have used more sauce. The breadsticks were literally just bread… No seasonings at all and the same with the cheese. Seemed like the cheese was from a can. I probably won’t order from here again knowing there are so many other pizza spots with good reviews.
We will Never eat here again

I had heard great reviews about this place and was excited to give it a try. On our first visit we ordered a pizza and their fultztix on a whim. I have to say, there was nothing memorable about the pizza BUT we have gone back multiple times just for the fultztix. If you like garlic these are for you. They are literally dripping with garlic butter and are crunchy and chewy at the same time. Needless to say we will not be back for the pizza but we will always go out of our way for an order of their fulztix.