Should have known this would be terrible but i figured since i was close to coney island to try it. It was overpriced and below average. Didnt look too clean in there either. Didnt expect much in the first place but still expected better
Winnie L.
Place rating: 1 Brooklyn, NY
This was the worst food experience I’ve had. Came here for their bacon fries to find that they were very soggy and the wings I ordered were horrible. The tenders were alright, but they messed up my order. I would recommend a different Nathan’s at another location.
Mei C.
Place rating: 1 Brooklyn, NY
This place is nasty and disgusting. The food are over priced. Ordered a bacon ranch fries, the fries are soggy even though it was freshly made and the bacon tastes like it came from a box. The employees are really loud and they got my friend’s order wrong. WORSTNATHAN’S EXPERIENCEEVER. I DONOTRECOMMENDTHISPLACETOANYONE !!! * if I can give no stars, I would totally give it no stars cause this place is that bad *
Scott L.
Place rating: 1 New York, NY
Disgusting … dirty … overpriced … and they NEVER get your order right … their only saving grace is that their french fries are good!
Cindy N.
Place rating: 2 Brooklyn, NY
Err… not the best experience. Hot dog was cold, poor service, and kinda dirty… I dont think i will be coming back to this location.
Karol L.
Place rating: 2 Brooklyn, NY
This is the only Nathan’s in my area so that’s the only reason why I’d come here. Their service is horrible but I will give them 2 stars because the last time I went, the employee there was actually nice.
Angela R.
Place rating: 4 Brooklyn, NY
I am very surprised. Nathens finally got their act together! They now have table service(you order your food and they bring it to you at your table), which is a convenience for all of the customers. The food has also improved and it looks like they clean it regularly. They also have new staff and they even have 2 flat screen tvs! The only other change i would like to see in nathens is for them to lower their prices. Good job Nathens!
Edna C.
Place rating: 1 Astoria, Queens, NY
terrible service, old crowd, expensive. oh but the hot dogs are decent.
Michael G.
Place rating: 1 New York, NY
Clearly I checked in here by mistake… delete!
N S.
Place rating: 1 Orangeburg, NY
Not fresh, very disappointing flavor
Daniel M.
Place rating: 3 Stapleton, Staten Island, NY
Nathan’s the only place that can get away with charging you $ 30 for 2 Frankfurters. I think the prices are outrageous but isn’t everything now a days.
William C.
Place rating: 4 Brooklyn, NY
sorry, but i dont care to chill with dirt bags, crackheads, and tourists to get my Nathan’s fix. conveniently located about two miles from my job, we get there, eat, relax, and make it back just in time for the lunch buzzer to let us know we’re safe. PS: Dyker Park Bagels is right across the street. your diet is officially f**ked!
Pinky And The B.
Place rating: 3 Manhattan, NY
I need to just correct the neighborhood, this is Dyker Heights it is right across the street from Dyker Park bagels. Unilocal has them both listed as Bay Ridge but they are both down the block from Dyker Beach Park which is listed at Unilocal as Dyker Heights. It is a division in Dyker Heights called Dyker Park. We use this Nathans bathroom and my hubby always gets a Nathans here. But like most of the locations it is not as good as the original in Coney Island.
Diana m.
Place rating: 4 Brooklyn, NY
The hot dogs still don’t taste as good as the original in Coney Island but they are still pretty good. I can never understand that by the way. It’s the exact same set-up, perhaps it’s something psychological.
Honest R.
Place rating: 5 New York, NY
Service at 7th Avenue &86th Street. The lady at the drive up window serves you your correct order all the time(which is different than most drive up windows). The breakfast is great! It’s hot, fresh, and perfect. I have been driving up to this window for many years, and never once has my order been incorrect. This is a refreshing change from drive ups! Out of maybe hundreds of drive ups there are probably two or three that will actually get your order correct! IT’s not the employee’s fault. The corporations do not give them enough time to serve people. Nathans ROCKS!(Indoor service is good too)! If you look at my TOP Restaurants you will notice that NATHANS is number one. And if you are questioning that and wondering why, then you just were not born in Brooklyn, New York. Nathans fries are the best in the world and when you are born in Brooklyn, you know why Nathans is number one on anyone’s list.