Benny’s Famous Pizza

I’d like to preface this and state that I have NEVER posted a review before.
This place is famous alright– famous for the multiple pieces of curly hair found in my mushroom pizza.
GROSS! Don’t order from here!

Gr8 pizza… Real quality… worth the price. This is gourmet pizza not discount pizza. Enjoy the food… I do!

Came here because it was crowded.
Always wanted to taste kosher pizza and finally tasted it here.
Ordered a slice of the falafel pizza and regular cheese. Both very good. Not too oily or greasy or too much cheese and sauce. It tasted very yummy.
Dough was a little bland BUT that’s how I like it. Not too salty or oily. Just right b
Loses a point because of prices.
$ 3.50 for falafel slice– slightly pricey

Great food, normal pricing for Kosher Dairy. Hands down the Best & Most consistent (Kosher) Pizza in Brooklyn, hands down.

Garbage pizza. Absolutely rubbish. I was in the neighborhood to eat some paletas at the local Hispanic place. I decided to take a walk to the bank on 13^th Ave on this beautiful spring like day and had a huge craving for pizza.
My dinner plans were to head to L&Bs on Stillwell, but decided that a cheese slice would be so satisfying right now. I walked into Benys and ordered a slice. The gentleman tossed the slice in the oven, and in no time, I took my first bite.
It was absolutely disgusting! I have no idea how the crust can feel rubbery, but that’s the best way I can describe it. The cheese was on the light side and it was all stuck together as if the cheese was an after thought top layer. I could’ve peeled the entire top layer (cheese) off as if it were a sheet of paper!
I honestly think it was an overnight slice that was just heated up. But that wouldn’t be possible since I ate at 1pm.
Never again will I eat here. If you can’t get a basic cheese slice right, I wouldn’t want to touch anything else they serve.

the best tasting pizza in Brooklyn