Good local spot. Easy parking and you can tell the customers are treated like familiar friends. The slices are delicious and fairly priced… Wish the toppings were heated along with the pizza but perhaps that’s a matter of taste.
Kate R.
Place rating: 3 Newton, NJ
Decent local pizza place. Personally I prefer the Newton location, but this location is pretty reliable. As someone else already posted, it’s definitely not that appealing of a place to eat-in, but it’ll do if you’re in a rush!
Kathleen D.
Place rating: 4 Branchville, NJ
We’re local and love it! Great pizza for sure.
Melinda S.
Place rating: 1 Branchville, NJ
Why are people writing good things about this place? When I first moved to Branchville 2 years ago, I thought the pizza was sooo good. Then All-of-a-sudden, it has been going downhill. My to go orders ALWAYS have a mistake, the breaded chicken sandwiches are pounded so thin that when you bite into one… watch out, you may chip a tooth. We keep giving them another chance because maybe they were having an Off day… Then recently, we ordered a pizza with peppers and mushrooms… sausage and onions… the two teaspoons worth of peppers were diced and looked like they were just thrown in the middle, the mushrooms were canned mushroom and sausage? What sausage? And the onions were cold and RAW! So, we had to add more cheese to the pizza and put it in OUR oven for 15 minutes until it was cooked! I think they have the kids cooking the food there. My advice, go somewhere else… seems the bar is where they focus their attention on. because it sure isn’t the food! Now we order from Jimmys Pizza… a little bit further, away, but at least they focus on the food there. Sorry A&G Branchville… no more chances…5 strikes… you’re out!
Rob B.
Place rating: 5 Branchville, NJ
Very good small town pizza place
Katherine V.
Place rating: 3 Haledon, NJ
The food is good. But. I called with a to go order. I ordered 3 items one of which was a large ham broccoli and tomato calzone. 45 min later when my order arrived I received a pizza with ham broccoli and tomatoes. I called and they did NOTHInG to remedy the situation. The man on the phone said«well they wrote down pizza» did not have any concern that my order was wrong or that I was willing to pay to have the right order delivered. I fear I was charged for a calzone and received a pizza. Pizza was okay but customer service is seriously lacking. There are plenty of other pizza places where they listen to your order and if a mistake is made they will be wiling to make it right.
Mike M.
Place rating: 5 Los Angeles, CA
Typical pizza/Italian place that I’ve been coming to for probably over 15 years. Price has been going up but so has every other pizza place. I love the pizza. At times the sauce is a little watery which I can see some people not liking. Either way it’s a little different than other places but good in its own right. I’ve also had the cheeseburger(surprisingly good), the steak and cheese(very good) and all the calzones are good as well — I always ask for no ricotta, but that’s just me. Fries are the classic fries u get anywhere else. They have good side salads. You can also order large pasta dishes a few days ahead for a party. They’re always really good. Small bar that’s often full if u wanna stop in for a drink. Never really gets rowdy or anything so if u wanna eat in with a family there’s no problems with that. The only complaint is on Friday nights it’s insanely busy. You might have to wait if u call in or when u pick up your order. Lastly, I’d recommend trying the place as I know they have given a lot of support to the local community organizations. Long review, but I’ve been coming here for a long time. That is all.
Joshua V.
Place rating: 2 Lexington, MA
Their steak and cheese sub is okay. Their pizza is soggy, and they use canned ingredients, not fresh.
Kimberlee D.
Place rating: 1 Sparrow Bush, NY
My boyfriend witnessed the man that makes the pizza in the men’s room not wash his hands and go back to his work station and start back to work! We told them we were not paying for the pizza and left. They took it off the bill but GROSS!
John W.
Place rating: 5 Branchville, NJ
Always great pie. My wife loves their antipasto salad, Kids love the wings Very good white pie as well
Shannon L.
Place rating: 3 Brookline, MA
A G’s is my family’s place of choice for take out on a Friday night when no one feels like cooking. Decent pizza, garlicky pasta dishes, and a chicken parm sandwich that is my personal favorite in the area. It’s cheap and super convenient(the other location is right off route 15 in Lafayette). They deliver too. I wouldn’t recommend eating in, because there is a bar inside and it tends to attract a slightly less than desirable crowd. I’ve never had bad service, but then again, never astounding service either. Typical pizza joint.