NY Giant Pizza

This is really good pizza and we got the 28 inch so we had plenty of left overs. It’s really good warmed up in the oven the next day too… the crust stays firm. If you’re a fan of simple thin crust pizza this is the place for you. Customer service was good as well.

Pizza was meh. Reminded me of Little Caesars. Prices are cheap, at least.

Bought a large pizza with pepperoni and olives. Very greasy and not much flavor. Delivery was fine, typical time frame. Just wasn’t that impressed.

Amazing pizza! My boyfriend and I ordered this after we have been wanting to try it for so long. I would definitely order this again! It’s a bit pricey in my opinion for pizza, but worth the money!
We didn’t get a giant pizza and got the 22″, but it was still HUGE! We love this place and will definitely come back.

This place is my go to pizza place. I live in South Boise and they are one of the only places that will deliver to me even though I’m farther away from them than others. More importantly their pizza is the closest thing I’ve found in Boise to actual NY pizza. Last the «Large» is comically large. It’s hilarious. I’m pretty sure the delivery guy has to put it in his trunk.

Great pizza! Like the name says, GIANT pizza. I can’t speak on the NY aspect since I’ve never been. Their pizza slices are rather large. They have a deal where you get two large Slices and a drink for a very good price. The employees are friendly and rather quick once you make your order. I haven’t been disappointed by their service and I doubt that will happen. The establishment is located next to the Edwards 21 theatre which makes it rather convenient after or before a movie.

This place is awesome! IMO the best pizza I have had in the Treasure Valley thus far and reasonably priced! They also have free delivery as long as you live in the area. The first time I came to the shop, but the second time we ordered delivery and it only took about 45 minutes to arrive. The combinations on their specialty pizzas are spot on and delicious. I would suggest playing it safe and let the professionals handle mixing and matching your toppings. The pizza is thin crust and saucy (yet the crust doesn’t get soggy).
Try this place, you won’t be disappointed.

Ordered food for delivery over an hour ago, and never got it. Called and said I wanted to cancel and they said I had to call the ordering company myself to cancel it.

Eeh! I have had the real thing & Im sorry to say, this was not it! The cheese slice tasted like sauce, not a delicious blend of crust, sauce & cheese. The garlic cheese bread was dry & tasteless. Ive had better at Domino’s. I noticed the lady at the next table ordered a side salad & it was delivered on a pizza tray covered by the wax paper the pizza was served on. It just seemed tacky to me.

This pizza rocks and, now, I can say it rocks consistently (at least for two deliveries). First of all, I cannot believe that they deliver for free. I have avoided ordering from this place because of the fact that it’s located next to the humongo-​dome theaters on Overland. I figured, it’s just a place for people who finish a movie and are wandering around this strip-​mall-​esque environment. I was so wrong.
The pizza is probably the best NY style I’ve ever consumed. The flavors are great, but it’s the texture I love. That crust is perfectly thing, but oh, so substantial, chewy, marvelous. It’s so good, I don’t even have that much to say about it. It might appear pricey at first, but you get a huge amount of pizza for your money. Seriously, give them a shot and you won’t regret it.

Good stuff!
We had two lunch specials with 2 slices of pizza each and a soda. We had a total of two cheese slices and one with olives and one with sausage. The slices were HUGE no exaggeration and the two slices with toppings had a generous amount of topping and the cheese had a little extra shot of herbs which provided a nice kick of flavor. The crust was tasty with just the right amount of crunch.
Next visit I’m going to order one of the 28″ whole pizzas to take home to the family.

Our go-​to delivery pizza. It’s reliably good, you can order online, and always delivered within a reasonable amount of time. I always order the veggie with canadian bacon — the veggies are fresh, crisp and the pizza cooked to perfection. Thumbs up!

Easily the best pizza I’ve ever tasted. I’m 29 and have quite the unhealthy fetish for pizza. Do I know anything about what makes it so great? Only what I enjoy about it. This NY style pizza is exactly that. Large, thin and full of flavor. The garlic bread sticks things were the bees knees. (Idk how to spell it)
Full of flavor, cheesy but not over doing it, crunchy but not dry, amazingly delicious. 5 stay worthy.

One of the best businesses that I’ve ever run into! And absolutely amazing pizza on top of it!
My order was initially messed up and lost. While some businesses out there will just deliver it without saying much, these guys were completely different. Not only did the manager/​owner call me to personally apologize, they stayed open after hours to correct it and delivered the order for free! I can tell you right now that hardly any business out there today will go through that much trouble to right a wrong… and these guys deserve all 5 stars because of it!
For the pizza, I got the tomato margarita with pepperoni and bell peppers added. It was absolutely amazing! The crust was cooked perfectly and the ingredients were perfect!
Again, absolutely amazing service that I plan to share with everyone around! Great job on the manager/​owner who personally delivered it to me too!

It just gets BETTER AND BETTER! I love how this place is a few feet away from the Edwards theater it is the perfect location. I was in a movie munching on my stale nacho chips and lukewarm cheese, that costed over $ 5 THEN I realized I should have got pizza instead!
Hopefully you don’t do what I did and spend your money on overpriced tasteless theater food. Now I make sure before or after a movie I am getting a slice of Giant pizza or garlic cheesebread or BOTH! It’s super fast and cheap when you get it by the slice, it’s $ 6 for TWO slices and a ice cold pepsi!!(Combo) I also like that I get an authentic taste of NYC right here in my own backyard but nothing is worse than spending $ 20 on popcorn, drinks, candy for 2 people at the theater then still going out to eat after lol.

Their pizzas are really big and the delivery is super convenient.
They taste deli and wish they had more flavors to pick from.

I really wanted to love this place, but I just wasn’t able to. The crust is pretty subpar in comparison to other NY style pizza in town. The guys working there were very friendly and I enjoyed being able to make my order online for carry-​out, but I don’t see myself grabbing another pie here anytime soon.

WOW! I just ordered one of their 28″ pizzas online. Despite knowing how big 28″ is I was not prepared for how large it actually was. The box barely fit through my front door. I enjoyed the taste of the pizza but my boyfriend disliked how the edges of his crust were hard (I didn’t feel the same way, I like it crunchy like that). All in all, I am very satisfied. Gave 4 stars only because they didn’t have Mt. Dew and had me subs. for Pepsi when they delivered my order.

I don’t get the hype on this place. I haven’t been to NY though so I don’t have any comparison to draw from, but honestly if this is what world famous NY pizza tastes like then I will pass. I thought the pizza was just okay, actually pretty unremarkable. You better eat it while it is hot though or else you are going to end up with gluey gummy cheese. We got a cheese pizza and a sausage and mushroom. But I thought both were just meh. Maybe there margarita pizza is better? I don’t know. I could see coming here for lunch if I just had a hankering for a slice and a soda, but with Costco right by you get better price and better pizza in my humble opinion.

Review for Pizza Delivery
Free delivery (min $ 11) but tip your delivery guy!
NYGP Boise only has a Facebook page but Unilocal doesn’t allow that to be added.
Hours are 11am-​10pm, 7 days a week
Menu:
Square is used for credit card transactions; receipt texted for delivery.
I ordered a 14″ Supreme ($ 12.99) — Pepperoni, sausage, canadian bacon, bell peppers, mushrooms, onions and black olives, to be delivered across the complex at the Spectrum Hampton Inn.
Delicious pizza with a thin crust with a good crunch. Toppings were evenly distributed and there is very little edge so if you’re the type that throws away crust, there is little to waste! Also, slices were cut through nicely — it’s annoying if it’s cut halfway and you have to rip your slices and rip wrong into the neighboring slice.
Expect around 40 mins+ for delivery even if you’re nearby. It’s an operational hurdle that very few small local pizza joints can work around, unless everything’s pre-​made or if they can afford many spare drivers.
Boise was hit with some crazy freezing weather early this year (negative 9 degrees on Saturday?!) and I wasn’t equipped to walk 0.4 miles, according to Google Maps, across the snow for food. Instead of national chains for pizza delivery, I opted for local joints and found that the new NY Giant Pizza has locations in San Diego and seemed to be well-​liked.
Called at 11am and the friendly guy repeated every number on my credit card aloud. He said it would be a «couple of minutes» which I knew was impossible, but whatever. At 11:12am, he called back to get my zipcode to complete the credit card transaction. At 11:40am, the delivery guy called to say that he’s outside my door. He didn’t know that payment had already been made and looked at the $ 3 tip money weird so I had to ask some awkward questions.
Overall, I enjoyed the hot delicious pizza and will order again.