New York Pizzeria

Binghamton, United States

3.3

Closed now

20 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 607-724-3030
Website:
www.binghamtonpizzeria.com
Address:
33 W State St, Binghamton, NY, 13901
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
0.6 miB.C. Junction
1.2 miConklin & Tompkins
1.4 miLegacy Bay
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
No
Delivery
Yes
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Good For
Lunch
Parking
Private Lot
Bike Parking
No
Wheelchair Accessible
No
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
Yes
Attire
Casual
Ambience
Casual
Noise Level
Average
Alcohol
No
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Wi-Fi
No
Has TV
Yes
Waiter Service
No
Caters
Yes

Today

Today 11:00 am – 11:00 pm
Closed now
Local time (Binghamton) 06:09 Wednesday, 16 July 2025

Business hours

Monday 11:00 am – 11:00 pm
Tuesday 11:00 am – 11:00 pm
Wednesday 11:00 am – 11:00 pm
Thursday 11:00 am – 11:00 pm
Friday 11:00 am – 11:00 pm
Saturday 11:00 am – 11:00 pm
Sunday 10:30 am – 9:00 pm

Description

Specialties

New York Pizzeria has become one of the most loved New York Style Pizzeria restaurants in the Binghamton NY Area. New York Pizzeria is home to the best gourmet pizzas in town. You will find over 30 Varieties of authentic NY Style Pizza with thin crust you’ll love, gooey Mozzarella Cheese, Fresh Tomatoes, and other fresh ingredients. New York Pizzeria prides itself on making authentic NY style pizza just the way you like it. Call Us Today.

Related places

You might also consider:
1
mi
Amici Pub & Pizzeria
126 1/2 Henry St
1
mi
Grotta Azzurra Italian Restaurant & Pizza
52 Main St
1
mi
Di Rienzo Brothers Bakery & Deli
152 Henry St
1
mi
Cortese Restaurant
117 Robinson St
1
mi
Nirchi’s Downtown
166 Water St
1
mi
Citrea Restaurant & Bar
7 Court St Ste 3

Nearby

Browse nearby places:
370
ft
McDonald’s
3 W State St
380
ft
Leather Corner Shoe Repair
Binghamton Plaza 33 W State St
380
ft
Bryant Heating & Air Cond
33 W State St
380
ft
Livingston’s Animal Kingdom
33 W State St
380
ft
Service Center Cpr
33 W State St
380
ft
The Pocket Billiard Lounge
33 W State St Ste 14

20 reviews of New York Pizzeria

No registration required
Place rating: 5
Yonkers, NY
The price is fair. The pizza is good. The bathroom is always well kept. Very clean establishment. Staff always is very friendly. I always come here with my son. He loves the pasta. I love the sauce for the spaghetti. When we order food for delivery they always come right away. By far the best pizzeria in town.
Place rating: 2
Binghamton, NY
I feel so bad for those folks that think this is real ny style pizza lol not even close.
Place rating: 3
Binghamton, NY
So sad, this used to be my favorite pizza place but I have not had good experiences lately! The last time I ordered a pie it was burnt on the bottom. I’ve never had burnt food before so I chalked it up to a glue and tried again. This time I ordered calzones and while they werent burnt, there was a hair in mine. Ugh. So I tried one more with my boyfriend and this time we got slices to go. They do have a great selection and he got chicken wing, taco, and white broc. I got mushroom pepperoni and a plain slice. Looking forward to them, we got home to find out they had put the wrong slices in our box and both mine were wrong! I should have checked the box but ugh!
Frustrated and Prob won’t be back for awhile which is sad bc they used to have a consistently great product.
Place rating: 4
Binghamton, NY
My favorite pizza restaurant around here. Im from downstate NY, I’ve had some good NY style pizza, and this is the only pizza that I’ve had from around here that is any good! They have many different toppings but I just love the plain cheese 2 slice with a drink special! Their garlic knots are good and their wings aren’t bad!
Place rating: 1
Hewlett, NY
Great pizza and great service.
Easily the best pizza in binghamton. I’m surprised that some people have them bad reviews. Always friendly over the phone and always get here quick.
UPDATE: got my food tonight everything was inedible. Took over an hour to get here. WILL NEVER GO BACK
Place rating: 5
Mt Laurel, NJ
Fantastic plain and pepperoni pizzas pizza. 2 slices with a drink and soup 11 bucks. Easy access to 81 for north and south travelers. Will be there again.
Place rating: 1
Lisle, NY
The past few times we have ordered, the pizza has been horrible. Last time the pepperoni pizza we ordered was undercooked and greasy, and this time it was so overlooked, the whole bottom was burnt. The only part of this pizza that was edible was the cheese and a small portion of the crust. We were very disappointed, and won’t be ordering again.
Place rating: 5
East Bronx, NY
Best Pizza in Binghamton!
Place rating: 2
Binghamton, NY
This place has stopped using a pre-​formed crust. Improvement there. The toppings can be generous-​if you get lucky on a given day. They are known, due to their inept staff (who prefer to stand around giggling and making comments about the customers) to get orders WRONG, or forget them altogether. You’ll be lucky if they admit to their error. The least offensive thing about this place frequented by denizens from that area of Binghamton would be a more legitimate crust. The rest of the process needs vast improvement, but I guess hiring competent, mature «help» is hard to come by.
Place rating: 5
Vestal, NY
I love this place. I only wished they delivered to Johnson City (I believe they only deliver to binghamton) — I would order from them much often. It’s genuine New York Style Pizza and they were very generous with the toppings. The crust is NY thin and crispy, and the sauce is tangy and adds to the flavor. If you decide to eat-​in, they have a huge display of many different pizzas and toppings to choose from. Even more than Nirchi’s. I highly recommend NY pizzeria.
Place rating: 4
Binghamton, NY
I JUST moved to Binghamton from LI, this is the first pizza place I tried… i’ll be back. Good pizza decent deal: 2 slices and a drink with one free refill 3.99
Place rating: 1
Wallkill, NY
Their pizza is trash, they gave me dry chicken wing chicken on my «buffalo chicken pizza.» See pics. Ridics.
Place rating: 3
Hoboken, NJ
Good not great pizza. Definitely one of the better options for upstate ny since options are limited. I wouldnt say its as good as nyc pizza but i would consider it a distant cousin.
Place rating: 4
Binghamton, NY
A classic NY pie! Great lunch special — 2 slices and a soda for ~5 bucks. Lots of different slices, good toothy crust, locally-​owned place. Nothing fancy. No alcohol served.
Place rating: 4
Binghamton, NY
Best pizza in Binghamton other than the mall’s pizza the closest thing to New York City pizza
Place rating: 2
Winter Park, FL
I ordered the calzone and the garlic knots. I was very disappointed. When i called to place my order i asked for a large and they said «yeah we serve a large» but when i got there it was a small and then they told me theres only one size. The dough they used for the knots was hard and chewy. Overall the food is bland, tastless and the owner is incompotent.
Place rating: 2
Centerport, NY
I grew up in Binghamton, believing that this was pretty mediocre pizza. No real reason to go unless you had to choose between it and Domino’s. But then I moved to New York City, and realized — nope, it wasn’t even mediocre. It was crummy.
The décor is fairly run-​of-​the-​mill, and the store is clean enough. Staff is pretty much hit-​or-​miss, and the prices are good.
The actual pizza, however… I’ve learned that you can just have a thin crust and call it «New York» — see, the pizza has to actually be –good-​. This floppy crust, bland sauce, and salty cheese don’t qualify. At their peak, they’re passable, but most times, I wonder again why I came in. (Because my best friend loves the place, that’s why.) Oh well. If you find yourself standing in front of the place with nothing but a few dollars and an empty stomach, go ahead, it won’t hurt you. But it won’t leave you with a taste of New York, either.
Place rating: 3
Collingswood, NJ
While I can’t vouch for the other pizza shops in Binghamton NY, I’m assuming the other reviews are accurate in stating that this is the best pizza in the area. I know that’s not really saying much.
The two slices + a drink for $ 4 is a pretty good deal and the slices are a good size. It appears that they had a lot of different pizza options including a taco pizza and a buffalo chicken which my friends seemed to like.
Taste wise, the pizza really wasn’t bad. I went with the pepperoni. It was a bit greasy, but not over the top.
The strip mall itself where it is located leaves much to be desired, but oh well. Decent pizza. Good prices. Ok bathroom.
Place rating: 5
Whitney Point, NY
Always pleased! Delish za awesome quick service. Love the two slice soda lunch deal.
A long time favorite of ours.
Place rating: 4
Mahwah, NJ
Cheap and delicious New York style pizza
This is about as good as it gets in Binghamton. The pizza is very good and they are extremely consistent. You will also find that they have a dozen or so different toppings already available by the slice. They have everything from 3 cheese to buffalo chicken. The pizza is good enough that even a plain cheese slice is excellent and I find that I don’t need toppings in order to enjoy the pizza.
This place is a great quick spot to stop for lunch. The service is always fast and they have plenty of seating. The plaza they are located in is quite questionable and sketchy but that’s part of the reason the prices are so cheap.
If you’re in the area for a quick lunch or dinner definitely stop here for a couple of slices.