Anthony’s Pizzeria

It is a great place to hang out with family and friends. You can build your own special pizza with whatever you want. Fast carry out service, great pizza, and best price!

Their pizza is really special and different from other place, glad I tried and love it! Definitely will going back, don’t forget to try their cookies, it’s amazing! And the Italian sub, those are pretty good as well!

I am not a pizza person. BUT! after tried Anthony’s, I come back every two weeks!!! LOVE it! They always make the best! INDEED BEST NEW YORK STYLE PIZZA IN COLUMBUS. NOT those traidtional greasy pizza.

The only reason I gave 4 stars is it’s too far from my home (I live at upper arlington area). Except that, everything at this place is perfect. I’ve been to the stats for 6 years and tasted for dozens of pizza places and this one is no doubt the BEST. It’s not just pizza they served but an art. With all the cheese, well, it’s worth to drive 30 minutes to there for a dinner twice a month.

Pretty great Italian food like pizza and subs. I love that it’s across the street from campus, so I don’t have to walk very fall for a good lunch!

Had the perfect Supreme pizza from this pizzeria today. Very friendly service, too. She mentioned that this is their first Sunday to open at noon instead of 4:00. So, go get your pizza and subs early on Sundays. This was my first visit, but will be back very soon, for sure!

Great pizza and great subs. Friendly little place and super fast for lunch. Will definitely be back.

Absolutely delicious New York style pizza. The employees are the most welcoming and friendly people you will ever meet at a pizza shop. They really do treat you like family! Top of my list for pizza joints around Bexley!

Awesome food! Great pepperoni pizza, came out perfectly. Hard to find good east coast pie in Columbus, and I think I found the one. Staff is nice, restaurant is clean. You can also build your own pizza!

Love their prices and pizza. Geat price. I’ve been there several times and always had great service and the delivery speed was pretty fast to

I’m from Michigan and was in the mood for some pizza after reading the reviews for Anthony’s, I decided to give it a try! I am not disappointed, the pizza was amazing but what was even better was the wonderful women working there! She talked to me like we were old friends and put me at ease right away! Next time business brings me back this way I’ll make sure Anthony’s is on my list!

We tried Anthony’s for the first time last night after driving by their clever signs since we moved here — have to say I was not disappointed — best pizza on pleasant ridge indeed! I especially appreciated that it came pie cut without me having to request it that way — a real plus for this east coaster. The pizza also tasted great — good sauce and cheese — maybe could have been a little more chewy but all in all a good pie.

Nicest people, they remember you and your order you don’t even have to say what you want lol me and another girl i work with go here all the time and we love it

From the phone call to the pizza–
BRAVO, Anthony’s !!
You’re extremely close to home (could walk if I wanted to!) and quick, without ignoring quality!
HATS OFF! Keep doing what you’re doing!!!
You may be small, but your customer service and quality of product are HUGE!!!

Slightly above average pizza, significantly about average price. Very motherly employees.

Great lunch spot! Staff, lunch specials, pizza all amazing. Nice outdoor seating on a sunny day

Sometimes, you just want some traditional, no frills pizza. Anthony’s is a great spot for that. I’d say it’s kind of a New York style pie. Thin crust and foldable slices. It’s just good pizza.
It’s a very small place. I’ve never seen many people eating there, but just a thought if you’re planning on it. After reading the reviews, I think I’ll try the Stromboli here next time!

This is not fancy pizza, but it is delicious. It has an old school feel to it and I’m hooked. It is just good, thin crust, almost NY style pizza. The restaurant has a few tables for dining in, but we’ve always gotten take out. The quoted times for pick up always seem to be accurate and the service has always been nice.
I think the pizza is priced fairly and you can get an XL pizza for less than $ 20. I think their pizza is better than Bexley Pizza Plus myself.
My only annoyance is the parking situation– they do have a lot behind the building, but the first time I went here, it was hard to figure out how to access it. You have to access the lot from Main St. and not the side street.

This is one of those places I wish I’d known about a couple years ago when I started working over this way. I had no idea they had pizza by the slice even after having it bookmarked for a few months now. I guess I never looked into the details.
The parking can be tricky, but when we went at lunch time on a weekday, we were able to find some parking on Main St. You can also park in their parking lot in the back, but you have to enter it from Main St. and not from Pleasant Ridge Avenue. You’ll see signs for Anthony’s right outside the building that edges up to Main, but the entrance and pizza shop is on the side.
The woman working the counter was super nice when we walked in, and it really felt like I was back in a college pizza joint, which makes sense, since Capital is directly across the street. My buddy and I really wanted some Italian subs, but we couldn’t resist pizza by the slice, so we got both.
We were both big fans of the pepperoni. It wasn’t anything extraordinary, but it was a pretty decent pizza and fairly cheap. I really liked the Italian sub, but my buddy wasn’t a fan of the Italian dressing. He thought it was too sweet, but I really didn’t get that at all. We both agreed the meat and bread and the rest of the ingredients were excellent.
Everything is made quickly, and there wasn’t really anyone in front of us when we were there. If it’s like that all the time, you can bet we’ll be back again for some more slices and sandwiches.

Really enjoyed our dinner here — the House Favorite pizza, which was simple, buttery and full of garlic-​ky goodness, and house side salads. Kind of the «good usual» one would look for in a pizza place. Small place, nice staff, doing good business on a Friday night. Going on the list of places for a quick bite before a movie or show in Bexley.