Three Brothers Pizzeria & Restaurant

I used to come to three brothers every time I came to NY just for there rainbow cookie cake. Omg it was amazing I don’t know what happened to it but getting rid of that was a huge fail … R.I.P rainbow cookie cake you will not be forgotten.

Seriously the best pizza in Bethpage. BY FAR.
–great friendly service
–clean
–always busy
–bakery Sicilian slice is on point!
–regular is amazing
–kitchen is also good
In a class of its own compared to any other pizzerias in the surrounding area!
Your missing out if you don’t choose this place.

Nasty owner, he was yelling at me while I had half a pizza pie left. He told me to go home. He has such a small place and limited staff. He had couples and me on a Sunday afternoon. They were finished eating and he did nit say a word to them. Imagine, going over to a woman and trying to oull her food away and then yelling to her to «go home, what else are yiu gonna do» he said

This place sucks I gave them so many chances every time I come in there they are out of pizza it’s ridiculous takes them 45 minutes to make a dish prices are very high and shitty attitude I’m through with this place I will go back to Mario’s pizza where they know how to treat you. its like they’re doing you a favor he’s too cheap to make a pie for fear that he might not sell it buy close how does a pizzeria by 730 not have slices I can’t figure it out go to pappardelle’s and boycott this place.

I’ve been here many times for pizza in the past. I like their pizza, though it is very overpriced. I’d recommend the baked ziti slice if you’re okay with having three meals in one slice of pizza. That’s a compliment, I swear.
We tried the restaurant side for the first time last night and it was mixed.
First thing I did was use the bathroom and I was surprised that there was a little tv screen in the wall. That was an interesting surprise. I guess it would be for anyone watching a game on their TVs. Seems like it’s more there for the owners, who always have the Mets game on if there is one, last night was no exception. I doubt many people spend that much time there that they need to watch the game in the bathroom, too.
Anyway, we started with the baked clams, which were okay. I’ve had better, but I still enjoyed them. My Caesar Salad was quite good, which always surprises me, because, I mean, it’s a Caesar salad, how good can it be?
Our server was patient with us (we took a while to pick what we wanted) but seemed inexperienced. He was replaced by one of the «Three Brothers» soon, anyway.
I ordered Baked Ziti with added ricotta cheese. I always figured ricotta was included with baked ziti, but I guess not. It was $ 2 to add it, but then again, the baked ziti was the cheapest pasta dish by about as much, so I guess they’re just covering all tastes.
Our entrees took a long time to be served. We were okay with this because we had plenty to talk about. We soo started to get pretty hungry, though.
One of the «Three Brothers» came out several times to make sure we were okay with water and bread, which was nice. It quickly became obvious he was covering for our food, that was taking much longer than it should, especially since we were one of the only two tables being served that night.
I thought it was odd that the dining room is so nice, yet the owner was wearing a Super Bowl T-​shirt when he served us.
Our food finally came out, and the results were very mixed. My baked ziti was pretty standard. Good amount of cheese/​sauce, pasta cooked through (not al dente like I like, but at least not overcooked and mushy). My girlfriend got the Fetuccini Alfredo that I tasted and it tasted like straight butter. Not the best. My mom got the fish plate and LOVED it.
The owner did, however, give us dessert on the house, which was very nice. The Nutella Calzone, a dessert he said isn’t on the menu just yet. Essentially a calzone stuffed with nutella and marzcapone, and topped with powdered sugar. Our suggesion was to include a knife to cut it with. Besides that it was delicious.
I had an overall mixed experience at Three Brothers. I do like their specialty slices, and for that I’ll probably continue going there. Besides that, though, I can take my pizza business elsewhere.

This place does not deserve even a one star rating. Waited a total of 30 minutes to get 3 slices and a hero and the place wasn’t even busy. Owners seem like they don’t care about their business or their customers and had nasty attitudes. If you are looking for soggy pizzas, gray deli meat, watered down sauce then this is the right place for you. Will NEVER return to three brothers again! You can get dollar slices that taste better than the food from this place. Very disappointed.

Very Nasty owners, They also overcharge you every time, Food just ok not worth going bad experience!!! NOT RECOMMENDED Very small slices they do not support community. I will never go back here.
FOOD TAKES 40 MINUTES TO COME OUT!

I went in here to grab a quick bite to eat after work. The guy behind the counter was not too helpful. I asked for Parmesan and it took 5 minutes to get that by the time I got it the pizza was cold. Cinnamon zeppoles were rubbery like chewing on a tire. All the pizza looked as if it was sitting out all day. Definitely will not be back here.

After my decision to eat in this place i was immediately taken back by the blatent rudeness of the young man behind the counter here. There is a problem with ordering all the time here either they are slow don’t care or just don’t want to help you it was almost like I was rushed and he was being very short like I was bothering him. This made me mad so much so that I was close to walking out after having placed my order.
I ordered a grandma pizza and a chicken parm hero when it came out almost 25 mins later it had very little chicken and the bread was soggy after I ask him to toast it. When it came to the pizza not only was the quality of the pizza terrible, but also tasted awful and stale like it was sitting out for days. (Not fresh)
I will not be visiting this place again and would advise others to also do the same. Being a local resident of Bethpage for 9 years I try this place occasionally and it’s always the same thing counter staff is horrible guess that’s why there is always a help wanted sign in the window, order gets messed up and the quality of food is just ok. There are so many pizzerias in the area. This is my last time ever going to 3 brothers of Bethpage.

Came in on a Monday night at 8pm with 3 other people with a groupon for $ 30 off. There were only 2 couples in the whole restaurant, but they asked us if we had a reservation. I looked around and said no but the place was empty. They sat us down and asked us if we had a groupon, which we responded yes. The waiter came back and told us we would have to wait a long time for our food because we did not have a reservation and they were busy. I looked around and said that there were only 2 couples in the whole place. He responded yes we are busy on the other side of the restaurant, I looked and there were 2 other people. No one ever walk in after us and one other couple left 5 min after we were seated, but we still had to wait 30 min for our food for no reason! This was a terrible way to get in new customers! Will not be going back! I gave it 2 stars because the food wasn’t bad.

I was fiending a slice of pizza and therfore went on groupon and found this little place in bethpage. It was split up into a dinning room and takeout. So we went to dine in as our groupon was a dine in only… it stated that alcohol was not included. And that they made delicious pizza. So when we sat down in the dinning room where the waiter dressed casually in a dirty tshirt politely gave us water (thank god cause the sahara dessert is cooler then this place) he instructed us that the groupon doesnt include alcohol, which we knew before hand so it was ok… but then he says oh and it doesnt include pizza either… ummmmm I bought a groupon from a pizzeria to eat pizza and youre telling me pizza is not included… are you freaking serious… ok so after showing him the groupon his answer is … groupon wrote that so no we cant serve you pizza at our pizzeria… I think three brothers should have the three brothers taken to kitchen nightmares so they can learn how to run an establishment. We were pretty hungry so we were going to pick a pie up anyways but when we saw the food sitting there none looked appetizing… so we drove to a spot thats always good, ciminellis… im writing this as im enjoying my slice of pizza… thank god my only good deciaion today was not eating at three brothers

If i can give them Zero stars i would! Came here with a group of 6 (3 adults and 3 children). First, it’s a Pizzeria/​Restaurant (separated) and there was no AC on this hot summer evening.
We order for the kids, Chicken Fingers for an appetizer, spaghetti with plain red sauce as their main dish and an order of 3 meatballs. The adults ordered personal buffalo pizza, Chicken Sorrentino and Chicken and Veal Parm combo. It took 50 mins for two spaghetti’s to come out (first dishes to come out). 10 mins later the «appetizer» (chicken fingers come out). Took another 10 mins for the 3 meatballs. All of the adult dishes took another 30 mins to come out. Keep in mind the place was empty with only one couple sitting on the opposite side of the room.
We asked for parmesean cheese, they brought us a container filled with chunky moldy cheese (disgusting). The adult dishes were nothing special. Chicken Sorrentino had no flavor at all, very plain.
Service was terrible, not attentive at all. We had to continue to get up to look for our server. Overall we will never return to this restaurant ever again. It’s actually sad because we are new to the neighborhood.

Cozy clean family owned local place. A few tables inside and a couple outside. Separate dining room. Very friendly service and they’re open till 10 which is later than most pizza places on a weeknight. So far the best pizza I have found in the area since moving here two months ago. The chicken Cesar was very good and the Sicilian as well. They have pizza, entrees, soup, wings and dessert.

Okay did not enjoy my 10 minute experience here…
I bought 1 sicilian slice and 1 salad slice and a water bottle… it was $ 9… yep $ 9 for two slices and a water bottle… of course no prices were listed anywhere so I had no idea if the sketchy guy behind the counter was gipping me or not.
The people behind the counter were scary… unprofessional… fighting with each other and cursing… They clearly hated working there and it made me want to leave.
and of course. my $ 9 pizza tasted like crap. I mean really… it had no flavor and was bland bland bland… That was far from NY pizza… the cheese was clearly not fresh as well. My Dad owned a pizzeria and trust me I know fresh food. This was not it
With all the pizza places around you would be stupid to waste your time here.

Make sure you come hungry! Both the pizzas and the pasta entrees come in good-​sized portions for the price you’ll pay.
Last time we were there we tried the Grandma Alla Vodka pie with the fried zucchini sticks as an appetizer. We should have left the zucchini alone, and not because it was bad. It was very good, and we devoured all of it! That was the problem, because then the Grandma pie came, and it was big! And it was also good! And we devoured all of it as well! And that was bad because we were stuffed by the end of it!
But, it was a good kind of stuffed. We’ll be back!

Stopped in for an eat-​n-​run business lunch. Place was empty but clean. Cute little sit down dining room on the side that’s probably more used at dinner time. It’s really more of a pizza and take out place. The Crusts tasted commercial and buttery, my guess its from a factory as I’ve tasted exactly the same crust at other pizza joints. I ordered a Chicken Parmigiana slice and a Plain Sicilian, both were acceptable, not special.

I agree with person above who wrote that the service is terrible. I ordered a baked ziti siciliana, and the counterperson quoted me a price that was three dollars above the price stated on the menu. When I pointed this out, he said that they reserve the right to change prices. When I got him down to the menu price, I noted that it was also Wednesday, and the sign in the window stated that it was a dollar off any pasta dish on Wednesdays. He said that was for seated customers only. I then proceeded to wait a half hour for my dish. When I finally went up to the counter it turned out that it was sitting wrapped up above the pizza oven, and no one had thought to call me. When I got home, I found there was no cheese on the dish. Because of course everyone knows BAKED ziti sicilian a doesn’t include cheese?!

The food is delicious! I grew up on pizza, hence am pretty picky, but their pizza is great… as good as it gets! They have an extensive menu in the dining room, weekly change of specials including fish, meats, and a variety of pastas. All food is fresh and prepped to order. If you are looking for a better bargain, they even feature specialty nights such as pasta and chicken night. The only drawback is the restaurant is either hit or miss, sometimes so crowded you have to wait, and other times where you are the only table. However, the staff is very attentive and friendly so worth a try! Highly recommended to all!

Booooooooooooooo! Worst service ever. It took a half hour just to get water. They ran out of bread. There was no toilet paper in the bathroom. They charged me for the wrong bill, which was $ 55 more than what I ate. Boooo. If you ever want to go out to eat and be totally pissed off afterwards, this is your place. I am going kick a pregnant dog in the stomach!!!

WOW this is good pizza! Get the alla vodka or the more purist Grandma’s!
As a born & bread NYer I was (OK am) a pizza snob. So Bethpage pizza? Ha!!! Well I’m a convert now. I stumbled on it after biking in nearby Bethpage State Park. Its great. In addition to all the standard slices they have about 4 square pies that are all worth trying.
The alla Vodka is a gooey cheesy mess of fresh mozzarella and vodka sauce on a thin but slightly too soft for my taste crust. The Grandma’s is thin crust (crispier than the vodka) with fresh chunky tomato, basil and mozzarella.
Its nothing like Patsy’s, Lombardi’s, etc so I wont even compare it but If I’m on LI I’d definitely make a detour for the alla vodka pizza and you should too.