Casual dinning that is consistently Delicious. This is our go to place, we love the eggplant, the pizza, and anything with sausage. Complimentary wine and service with a smile every time!
Chris L.
Place rating: 4 Bethlehem, PA
Unfortunately I don’t understand how this business doesn’t have more positive reviews. Maybe because people are so eager to look at the negative side right away. Anyway, living in Bethlehem for 11 years this is my favorite pizza restaurant to go to. It’s family owned and they are extremely friendly and welcoming. The food is great, and their pizza is delicious. Most dinners are delicious and something’s that need to be added. Overall, I wonder if the owners can see all of this, but they should ignore it and continue to run things how they been doing it for the past 10 years.
S K.
Place rating: 3 Phillipsburg, NJ
Typically, we eat pizza 1 – 2 times per month, and this is our go-to place for carry-out pizza. Carry-out orders are consistently ready within 15min or less. The employees are super friendly and professional. We are accustomed to pizza typical of NYC, and Sicily is the one we find most comparable within a reasonable driving distance to our house. The crust is not overly doughy, but maybe a little bland. We like their tomato sauce. Our only complaint would be that the toppings are rather SPARSE for the price you pay for them. We usually order just one topping, and are almost always disappointed at how little they put on the pizza. We tried ordering 2 toppings(each topping is an additional $ 2.50) to see if they would double the amount on the pizza, but the pizza simply had the usual sparse toppings divided evenly between our two choices. So, we keep it simple and economical, and just enjoy a pretty decent pizza from a nice little place.
Amy F.
Place rating: 2 Hokendauqua, PA
Ordered a white pizza with broccoli. Double checked to make sure there would be ricotta on it. The pizza we got was luke warm, BARELY had ricotta, no garlic, no flavor and was dry. The crust was decent, and it looked good but missed the mark on flavor altogether.
Gregory K.
Place rating: 5 Bethlehem, PA
I have lived in Bethlehem for 27 years, this is my favorite place to get pizza and garlic knots!
Lyndsay K.
Place rating: 4 Peachtree Corners, GA
I can’t do 5, sorry. Maybe I should have tried the pizza instead of the stuffed mushrooms and sausage parmagana wrap, but I didn’t. Solid four, though. Very solid.
Joseph C.
Place rating: 5 Easton, PA
Best regular slices in Lehigh Valley that this Italian-American Ex– New Yorker has tried out here thus far. Sicilian is not as great, as typically doughy in this area. However the pastas and meals are excellent for this type of establishment. Prices are good. Ceasar Salad is very good too!
Tom B.
Place rating: 5 Bethlehem, PA
If you are the type to measure the success of a place based on the fact that they don’t need a coupon, gimic, or BOGO to get people to try their stuff. This place kind of falls into that catagory. I don’t think I’ve ever seen any kind of special offered here… and the bustle of the joint kind of dictates it isn’t needed. They used to have a tie to the Sicily Pizza in Nazareth, but I’m not sure if they do or not anymore. Because of proximity, this ends up being my families«go-to» place… as well as a ton of other people in the area on any given night. The pizza is pretty good and fairly priced, the steak sandwiches are good… and the staff is pretty attentive. They are always willing to put together a special order pie if you want. I haven’t ordered a ton of their pastas, but when I go in to pick up my order, there always seems to be people at the tables chomping away. Their personal sized sausage roll is one of my favorites, but also have enjoyed their Philly Cheesesteak Pizza(and make sure you order it that way… not just a Cheesesteak Pizza… two different things). Give them a shot for sure… I am struggling between 4 and 5 stars… If I had to give 4 it would only be because I can’t honestly judge their pasta… maybe an update after a few orders of it
