Westside Pizza

Constructive feedback — ordered in person a medium mushroom pizza to go. Took 45minutes to get my pizza (what?!) Even people who ordered after me, in room dining got their pizza before me. And when I got my pizza I had to look very closely to double check if I got just a plain cheese pizza because there were a minimal smattering of mushrooms. Mushrooms were not hidden under the cheese either. When someone orders a one topping pizza please put the correct sufficient amount of topping! –also I paid $ 13.99 for the pizza but as I walked out I noticed a standing special of two of what size I ordered for $ 4 more. The cashier could have suggested that, just a suggestion Westside! And hours later I am parched beyond! Something on your pizza was very salty. Way too salty. I’m Italian, and know pizza– this is way too below the acceptable line of pizza. I know you guys can do better. I love local business and want to see you succeed with a great pizza product not just because you are only a few options on the island. Don’t skimp on toppings, don’t take 40+ minutes to turn out a pizza, and get the sauce or cheese right. Salty is not a flavor. You get two stars instead of one because your customer service by the guy handing me my pizza apologized for taking so long.

Can’t say enough about the amazing customer service we received at this establishment-​the manager Shey on two occasions went above and beyond to take care of my family and friends to make sure we had the best evening out — enjoying delicious pizza– great beer selection and fun atmosphere !

The best thing going for them is the staff. They are polite, helpful and couldn’t ask for anything more. Great location and nicely decorated.
The cons: SO MANY FLYS!!! I know it’s fruit flies season but there had to be over 50 flies flying around us. Second recommendation is to fix the gluten free crust, it’s probably the worst I’ve ever had.

Really great pizza and they even delivered to the state park for us. The family devoured the big kahuna and gourmet veggie. I will be returning!

I absolutely love this pizza place. It’s my new favorite place and it’s SO, SO Good! I enjoyed it very much… Beware of Death it’s addicting and this Pizza is Yummy!!!

Best pizza around! LOVE the Margarita pizza my fav for sure. Great little pizza joint with amazing staff.

Great pizza! You can tell they use fresh, quality ingredients. Came out hot and delicious. Got the biggest size half & half for only $ 25, enough to feed 6 people. Looking forward to coming back.

Michele is amazing! We had a great lunch due to her wonderful recommendations! Definitely coming back

Decided to order delivery from these guys, since I am new to the island and we had a looooonnnng day moving all our stuff into the new home. We decided to treat the moving guys to some pizza and soda, so I decided to give Westside a call. I ordered a meat lovers pizza and a cheese (for my vegetarian wife). We were both pleased with the sizes of the pies as well as the fact that they were fresh upon arrival to our door. The delivery kid was professional and prompt. The moving guys seemed to dig the pie as well. I would order from them again or even just stop by and get a slice for lunch.

The best place to have a beer AND hang out with your family while watching sports and have a meal that everyone likes. This is a hard combo to satisfy on the island!

How I heard of this place: On a little jaunt to the Island, west of Seattle, my husband and I shared a lovely afternoon with my in-​laws, where they treated us to a Tuesday-​special lunch: two slices and a beverage for $ 3. We made our way up the stairs of Winslow Mall’s outdoor courtyard half-​way through our walk up and back down the main street of Bainbridge Island’s quaint, little town.
Type of cuisine: Pizza. Two toppings per special. A case of bottled and canned beverages.
Ambiance: More of an in-​and-​out style lunch pick-​up, no seating is found within the confines of the Westside Pizza kitchen and order counter. Simply walk in, view the rotating pizzas on the windowed display shelves to your right, make your selection, pay to the left and walk out with your beverage (taken from the refrigerated stand-​up display at the left of the door). Once back in the covered walkway of the Mall, a couple of picnic tables with umbrellas above are available for seating. That is, if they are not completely taken up by the high schoolers who are there for their daily special $ 1.50 per slice, buy two get a soda for free!
What I ordered: Two slices mushroom and pepperoni with a can of Pepsi. My husband and I shared this half of the pizza, while my in-​laws selected sausage with mushroom and sausage with green bell pepper on their half.
What I loved: Cheese. Lots and lots of gooey cheese, slightly spicy pepperoni and thin-​cut sliced mushrooms.
Why I loved it: Simple. Inexpensive. Quick. Family friendly.
Cost: Low ($ 3 — $ 4 per lunch hour special: two two-​topping slices with a beverage)