Vinny’s New York Pizza

Atlanta, United States

4.3

Closed now

20 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards
Free Wi-Fi

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 404-872-0484
Website:
vinnysmidtown.com
Address:
860 Peachtree St, Atlanta, GA, 30308
Midtown
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
960 ftMidtown MARTA
0.2 miMidtown
0.2 miCollege of Business
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
No
Delivery
No
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Good For
Lunch
Parking
Garage, Street, Validated
Bike Parking
Yes
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
Yes
Attire
Casual
Ambience
Casual
Noise Level
Average
Alcohol
Beer & Wine Only
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Wi-Fi
Free
Has TV
Yes
Waiter Service
No
Caters
Yes

Today

Today 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Closed now
Local time (Atlanta) 09:51 Friday, 29 November 2024

Business hours

Monday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Tuesday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Wednesday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Thursday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Friday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Saturday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Sunday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm

Description

Specialties

Real ny pizza!

Related places

Explore similar places:
740
ft
Newk’s Midtown
933 Peachtree St Ste 921 (Midtown)
1
mi
Baraonda Italian Restaurant
710 Peachtree St NE (Midtown)
1
mi
Ray’s Pizza
26 5th St NW (Midtown)
1
mi
Domino’s Pizza
44 10th St NW (Midtown)
1
mi
Ribalta
1080 Peachtree St NE Ste 9 (Midtown)
1
mi
Pizza Hut
929 Spring St Nw (Midtown)

Nearby

Near this location:
60
ft
Eyedeology Vision Center + Optique
860 Peachtree St Ste F
90
ft
Spire Midtown
860 Peachtree St NE
100
ft
Fresh To Order
Spire Building 860 Peachtree St NE
110
ft
Five Guys Burgers and Fries
860 Peachtree St NE
120
ft
Beellagio Nail Bar
860 Peachtree St Ste G
120
ft
Señor Patrón
860 Peachtree St NE Ste H

20 reviews of Vinny’s New York Pizza

No registration required
Place rating: 5
Jersey City, NJ
Reminded me of home! Just what I was looking for! Fast and easy, NY style slice. Folks who were working we’re really nice, and they didn’t charge me for a side of ranch. Can’t beat that haha
Place rating: 5
Pittsburgh, PA
Great place! Cute pizzeria with some cool historic art pieces of Milan, London, and of course NYC. One of a few places open on New Year’s Day.
Place rating: 4
Apache Junction, AZ
Appreciated the warm greeting and recommendations made by the gal at the front. I wasn’t expecting too much but was pleasantly surprised by the great tasting crust and plentiful fresh pizza toppings. Nice environment with outdoor seating options in a fun corner in Midtown.
Place rating: 5
Jonesboro, GA
I only tried the cheese pizza and the pineapple pizza but lordddddddd, yesssssss, pizza heaven on earth! On top of that, my friend and myself both had came in like 30 – 20 minutes before closing and still had amazing and quick service. The girl who was at the register was so nice to us and helped us by telling us a little more about the items on their menu since it was our first time there. I’ll definitely swing by again to try the chocolate cannoli!
Place rating: 5
Lilburn, GA
Slices are huge and they put so many toppings on your pizza! A great place for a quick and hearty lunch.
Place rating: 3
Atlanta, GA
I generally love Vinny’s but my last visit was disappointing, only because of the pizza. We got some slices and they were just ok. Normally the sauce is much tastier. Maybe it was just an off day but I didn’t get that New York taste that we come for.
Place rating: 5
Atlanta, GA
Went today for lunch. My brother and I order a pizza to eat there. Very good pizza. Great flavor and crust. The restaurant is very clean and the staff in friendly. We met the owner and spoke to him for a few minutes.
If you’re close by and want pizza, go here.
Place rating: 5
Stafford, TX
Yum! I love the pizza here so much that I went twice in a row. My second time here was even better than the first as I experienced impeccable customer service alongside the delicious pepperoni pizza. My gf got «the works» & it was pretty amazing, I had to steal a few bites. The Pizza here has the tastiest crust (for a non-​crust lover), perfect crunch, well sauced, nicely portioned-​thin sliced and oh so cheesy! Can’t wait to try their Stromboli, Calzones and lasagna (which I noticed might be new).
Parking can be a hassle but it’s worth it.
My only regret is that I was too greedy both times and had eaten it all before remembering that I needed to share a pic with fellow Unilocalers.
I have tried the competitions off Peachtree, 14th street et al and I have to say that I’ll keep returning to Vinnys.
Place rating: 1
Doraville, GA
I did not personally eat here. But I had a bad experience with the one at the Northlake Mall. The young man who answered the phone could have brushed me off but he listened to me and patched me on to the appropriate person. Thank you young man (btw the Northlake Location sucks, the dude is rude .) He was trying to make me speak Spanish. English is my first language. So when he starts saying my name out loud and telling his coworker or whatever «This lady is named Margarita G and won’t speak Spanish“wtf does this have to do with me getting a damn pizza and a soda for my son? This is a weird discrimination situation that I will be pursuing This dude who worked behind the counter was a real piece of work. Male chauvinist pig. I will be posting all over and calling someone instead of the business if I do not get a response !!
Place rating: 4
Atlanta, GA
Solid by the slice pizza place. Thin crunchy crust, good quality cheese and flavorful toppings. It is actually what you would expect to find in a quality NYC place. The only draw back is that is carry the NYC price tag. Due to its location and I am sure high rent I give it a slight pass on what seems to be a high price for a slice. The outside seating is great for people watching and deciding where to get desert.
Place rating: 5
Atlanta, GA
Delish fresh baked pizza all the way to the crust. You will not want to eat the franchise pizza (Pizza Hut, Dominos, etc) after you taste these. Priced very reasonable and good portion especially their calzones are huge. My kids love’em and I love’em. On a nice day, you can sit outside with your pet too. Only part is that you have to park at the parking deck which they will validate for you if you give them the ticket but it’s a very short walk. Just remember not to park by the curb, it says «15 min parking» and they are not joking, I’ve seen some people get their car booted and I heard it’s like $ 100 to unboot them.
The staff is friendly and funny. Love coming here every time!
Place rating: 5
Atlanta, GA
Yay! I found my go to local pizza place! I have been here twice now. I’ve been to quite a few around the city and never was really satisfied. But thank goodness I came across Vinny’s.
The first time I ordered «The Vinny Special». It was amazing. Last night I ordered the Hawaiian Calzone. So good! There ingredients seem very fresh.
This has become my go to pizza place!
Place rating: 5
Atlanta, GA
The pizza was delicious! The people working there were friendly and the services was good. I will be going back!
Place rating: 3
Atlanta, GA
Parking: Deck is validated for 1 hour or 15 min on the street
Setup: Order at the counter. Dish will be brought to your table.
Food: 1 slice Vinny Special & 1 slice the Works (~$ 10 w/​tax). These slices were super filling and had a nice crispy crust. I enjoyed the Works better than the Vinny Special.
Service: Great staff at the counter.
Place rating: 5
Atlanta, GA
Best classic Italian with affordable price. The pizza is yummmmmm. The crust is thin crunchy and tasety (yes, i am a crust eater: P)
My most fav: the works and meat lovers
Others: lasagna, meatball sub
Desert: teramisu
Place rating: 5
Indianapolis, IN
WOW sone seriously good pizza and friendly service. One huge slice of Meat O Mania and I was stuffed. We had to get out of the tourist area around The Atlanta Aquarium and Coke to get something good finally. If we were from the area this would be my go to for pizza.
Place rating: 3
Edgewood, Atlanta, GA
Good casual place for a slice of pizza. Not artisanal, but not Pizza Hut either. It’s most akin to Fellini’s, minus some of the grease.
One thing that’s particularly good here is that their crust is nice and crispy. Not chewy like it’s been reheated, and not too crispy where it tastes burnt. It’s a good medium.
There is validated parking in the deck next to it. This is the parking for Spire Condos, and you can park anywhere that is in the retail section (first 2 floors).
Place rating: 3
Memphis, TN
I got a custom Sicilian pizza.
This isn’t going to be my longest review by any means. It is pizza for goodness gracious. I would like to come back and try a standard NY style pizza instead of the Sicilian. I didn’t know what I was getting myself into and I wasn’t a huge fan. The cheese and sauce was great. The topping weren’t my favorite. The service was good and the pickup time was as promised. I realize this is pretty vanilla and doesn’t give you much, but so was the pizza. Like I said, I would like to try the standard. The Sicilian is way to bready.
Place rating: 4
Atlanta, GA
Very tasty pizza and a casual low-​key atmosphere. I love to my pizza had more toppings than just crust. This meant that there was so much flavor every bite. I got just one slice of pizza and it was enough to make my stomach and my wallet feel satisfied. I would have liked to have had some larger tables inside but my friends and I were able to sit at one of the patio tables which was fine. Having to pay for nearby parking is a bit of pain but this pizza is good and my husband and I will most likely be coming back. I’m going to get a slice of mushroom pizza next time. I got to try a bite of my friend’s mushroom pizza and the mushrooms tasted so fresh and wonderful.
Place rating: 5
Decatur, GA
Best pizza in Atlanta I have had, to date! Especially if you are interested in the famed «New York style» pizza (the NJ-​bred bf will vouch for this) with huge slices so thin it just makes perfect sense to fold them in half lengthwise (or what I like to think of as bisecting the angle).
We have been here on a number of occasions, and the pizzas are always so consistently delicious.
We generally split a whole pie between us, with half white (no tomato sauce), half meatball. I can eat only about two slices before I cry uncle; my manly counterpart generally gets through three! Which still leaves us three huge slices as leftovers, all for about 18 bucks after tax. So, pricier than your bottom-​rung Domino’s or Pizza Hut, but the step up in quality and taste isn’t something you can really put a price tag on.