Goodfellas Pizza in Athens, OH

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:	+1 740-592-1572
Address:	6 W. Union St, Athens, OH, 45701
Categories:	Pizza

Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations	No
Delivery	No
Take-out	Yes
Accepts Credit Cards	Yes
Parking	Street
Bike Parking	No
Wheelchair Accessible	No
Good for Kids	No

Good for Groups	Yes
Attire	Casual
Alcohol	No
Outdoor Seating	No
Has TV	No
Waiter Service	No
Caters	No

Today

Today	–
Local time (Athens)	04:02 Wednesday, 16 July 2025

Business hours

Monday	–
Tuesday	–
Wednesday	–
Thursday	–
Friday	–
Saturday	–
Sunday	–

Related places

Nearby

Browse nearby places:

The Other Place

43 S Court St

Whit’s Frozen Custard

49 S Court St

Epic Sandwiches

Union and Court St

Cross Court Cards & Gifts

45 S Court St

Jack Neal Floral

80 E State St

100

Inhale Yoga

63 S Court St 2nd Fl

13 reviews of Goodfellas Pizza

No registration required

James Y.

Place rating: 5
Athens, OH

Uniique pizza. Great taste if you like dough. Which I do :)

Dani B.

Place rating: 1
Athens, OH

Service was fast & friendly, but this is DEFINITELY drunk food only. I heard a lot of people talk about it, but i couldn’t even eat a whole slice because it was so gross.

Miggs M.

Place rating: 4
Athens, OH

It’s pizza by the slice! So what do you expect? Garlic buttered crust, decent prices, and a delicious blend of thin and thick pizza. Definitely ask them to cook your piece longer. Even at its worst, Goodfellas is better than a majority of everything else out there.

Ryan D.

Place rating: 4
University District, Columbus, OH

I wish there was a Goodfellas in Columbus. just saying. Something about their thick sheets of pizza just always hits the spot (more so after a few pints). I almost always stop and get some when I am in town, if even just a slice for the ride home.
Prices are pretty reasonable as well… also never tell them you want a FULL sheet unless you know what the Full sheet is. Made that mistake once. but it turned out for the best.

David P.

Place rating: 1
Columbia, MO

Not good. Basically, a big hunk of undercooked bread disguised as pizza.
Smelled delicious and was served quickly by a friendly worker but I was definitely too sober to eat here.

Garrett L.

Place rating: 5
Cincinnati, OH

Love this pizza ! The fact its local makes it much more amazing and the rolls served on occassion are awesome too ! just prepare yourself that there is a lot more bread on the pizza than a average pizza for the purpose of drunks.

Jillian P.

Place rating: 3
Cleveland, OH

AWESOME when you’re drunk. Mediocre when you’re sober but I’d rather get their pizza than one of the chains (Domino’s, Donato’s, Little Caesar’s) regardless of my intoxication level.

Matthew G.

Place rating: 5
Columbus, OH

The current holder of my personal «Best Pizza in the World» title. The dough is wonderful, I think they use bread flour in it. Just the right amount of grease. A perfect sauce. Priced to feed poor students, but fit for a king. Maybe some alumni won’t admit it, but this place is the *real* reason for homecoming.

Patrick C.

Place rating: 5
Columbus, OH

It’s a local business,
Ran by students,
Providing good cheap food,
Cool atmosphere,
Awesome Staff,
and Open Late.
Honestly anyone that complains about the variety of toppings can go cry some place else because the union shop will have specialty pizzas every day around noon time, and the late night pepperoni and cheese slices are all made fresh within a 20 min time. It’s thick slices, of soft cheesy pizza and you have the option of getting franks red hot, crushed peppers, ranch, and butter garlic. if you get a slice without one of these extra toppings you will be missing out a bit, but none the less its an athens staple that should be praised not torn down.
Holla out to the Goodfellas staff!

Frank N.

Place rating: 1
Baltimore, MD

Absolutely gross mound of undercooked dough with some cheese on top… Will you find NY style pizza? Absolutely not. Chicago Style? Close, but very underwhelming…
This place obviously survives on two key ingredients: cheap food and drunk students…
One star for friendly service.

Gavin D.

Place rating: 2
Yellow Springs, OH

Somehow, I remembered this as good pizza from my times in Athens a decade or so ago. Who knows, maybe things have changed, but it’s really not very good. More likely, as others have mentioned, I just hadn’t had enough to drink.
The crust is too bready and not crisp, and the flavor just isn’t there. It’s cheap, I will say that.

Dave T.

Place rating: 4
Huntington, WV

Limited selection but very tasty

Kiarash Z.

Place rating: 4
Tempe, AZ

I was warned that Goodfellas, much like Flash Taco in Chicago, is a place open until 3 a.m. that survives on drunk late-nighters not knowing the food they’re eating is awful.
I disagree. Goodfellas has a spongy, soft, tasty slice of pizza for $ 2.
Granted, I was drunk at 2 a.m. when I ate it.
And the people you’ll meet while waiting in line are priceless.

Goodfellas Pizza

Athens, United States