High Fidelity Records & CD’s

Not the most organized but definitely as organized as it could be. Great deals and fantastic finds if you look.
My boyfriend found an animé no longer in print for a decent price and I went home that same day with 5 awesome vinyls. Can’t leave disappointed.

I have been shopping at High Fidelity for quite a while now and I must say every experience I have there is wonderful! I am pleased with the patient knowledgeable service that both Mark and Jimmy provide. The prices are extremely reasonable and the merchandise never disappoints in terms of quality. I look forward to shopping at High Fidelity throughout 2016!

It is pretty hard to not walk out of High Fidelity without a few newly picked up records in hand. The store’s selection and pricing is phenomenal. Every day awesome new arrivals are coming in and the staff there is simply way cool. You can find me at High Fidelity more than anywhere else!

This is THE store and second to none.
Marc takes great joy in having a 2^nd hand record store stocked with whatever he can get his hands on so that his customers never leave empty handed. … and his priced are always fair.
The store evokes great music conversations due to staff as well as the customers who shop there.
… never a bad vibe and always a great pleasure to shop.

Place is top notch! I as well made a Unilocal account just to pay homage to this gem of a store. Like the whole idea of buying the hard copy as opposed to stealing it on the Internet good way to show a token of appreciation for the talent and hard work the artists we love have and do… that having been said I’ve been to other places like this and they have had about as much atmosphere as the moon glad a place so close to home is holding it down. Always more than helpful and insightful. I will be a customer for some time to come Thanks guys!

The best record store on Long Island.
Marc is a great guy and actually enjoys running his store, unlike about 90% of other record store clerks. His knowledge is encyclopedic, and is really good about ordering merchandise and getting you a good deal.
The place is simple and not filled with flashy distractions like overpriced merch or a stage where 12-​year olds can get dropped off in their minivan, watch punk, and not pay for anything. It’s not the «scene». It doesn’t have radio adverts or a mascot, or Twisted Sister autograph sessions, or a collection of Monopoly boards. The place doesn’t reek of incense. There are no Hot Topic shirts.
Simply: if you like good deals on used records, a very accessible New Arrivals section, and some informative Facebook posts about current acquistions, Marc and High Fidelity are the way to go.
For serious collectors and new hobbyists who just want the goods. Nevermind the bullocks, here’s High Fidelity.

Just went back there after a long time. The place is piled high with all kinds of random stuff and I can see myself spending at least a couple of hours digging next time. The prices are reasonable and although it is a bit crowded, the vinyl junkie who likes to dig through piles will have a great time there.

A real mecca for record collectors. Always an eclectic batch of «new arrivals» waiting in the browsers as you walk in. Mark must draw a great deal of high quality collections. Pays reasonable prices for the market and makes them available for his customers without ridiculous mark ups. Don’t be put off the first time you walk in and see «stuff everywhere!» that hasn’t been sorted out. There are treasures to be found and Mark will do his best to find them for you. I walked out with my arms full today and I will be back real soon to dig through the treasure trove again.

whoa whoa whoa, i had no idea this was even here. I went looking online for record stores as i just recently bought a turntable and came across this gem. What a find!!! Holy shit do they have a ton of stuff, i got some old Billy Joel, Bowie, Carly Simon and Squeeze and will def be back to find some more things, The guy that helped me was super nice and even tried to find a corny Helen Reddy Album for me, i will be back

Still the best and getting better. At last visit the store was jammed packed to the rafters, but well organized. Mark, the owner, knows where everything is located. Worth the trip if you are coming from the City or out of town. Most items are priced fair.
Best record store on Long Island and Best Owner !!! Always find something that I need and I have been collecting for 40 years !!! Great way to spend an afternoon.
Keep it up !!!

The owner is one of the nicest people I know and I find myself coming in at least once a week and finding awesome metal, punk and rock records. I’ve purchased a good chunk of my record collection here and I’ll be coming back for a very long time. If you’re in the Amityville area this store is a must for record lovers like myself.

Was in the area and finally made it over to check out High Fidelity a few
weeks ago. This shop is in an unassuming strip mall (with AWFUL and
limited parking I might add, I parked on the street nearby which was
much better) on Merrick Rd. in Amityville, and it’s not far from the site
of the infamous Horror House so how can you go wrong? I’m giving
this place 5 thumbs up because it’s one of the few good indie record shops
left on Long Island that’s even worth going to, the prices are reasonable
as near as I could tell, even for box sets new or used, and they had
a SEALED copy of Cheap Trick The Essential (collection) 3.0 ltd. edition CD that
I’d otherwise have ordered online, but why since they had it new, sitting
right in the bins?! Instant essential road trip CD made use of immediately.
As Robin Zander says, «Gigo lo is the only way to go!»
Yeah I can put it on the iPod but more fun to have the actual item in the
car in tangible form, I think. The owner or manager was a good chap
and was friendly and unfailingly helpful. The shop isn’t gigantic but it is
well-​stocked and chock full of goodies, you really need to take the time
to stand there and dig and search and you will find some gems.
Some of the new or reissue vinyl up front was a bit steeply priced,
but that’s the case at a lot of NYC shops these days as well. I will definitely
be returning to High Fidelity, and soon, and can’t think of anything negative
to say about it: we need more shops like this again on L.I. but sadly
I don’t think we’ll be getting them anytime soon. But I truly believe
High Fidelity is worth the trek.
Shame the area is so unutterably barren. Amityville isn’t a bad town, don’t get me wrong, it has its beautiful spots, but overall long stretches of the south shore of L.I. are kind of dullsville. But hey, there’s the Horror House, the evil pig,
James Brolin’s Ghost, All-​American Burger in Massapequa, and
High Fidelity to assuage our sense of L.I. homogenized boredom!

This is another great music and DVD store. They have so much stuff crammed in and it’s all fairly cheap. It’s also closer to home for me then Mr. Cheapos is. It’s comparable to Mr. Cheapos. I bought a few CDs here when I still had my car and listened to them a couple of times.

Great record store. There is a huge selection crammed into that little place. The prices are average and the quality of used records is excellent. To say the guy running the place is knowledgable about music is an epic understatement. They run a decent promotion to keep you coming back. They also update their customers regularly of new stock via their facebook page. Probably because of guys like me who will drop almost anything to run over there to pick up that one record I’ve been trolling ebay for like a maniac.

This is a great record store. I only started going to this store in the past year, but every time it is a positive experience. I’m keeping my rating at four stars until I have had a little more experience with this place. This is the real deal though. A real record and cd shop, with a real music guru who runs it. Prices are average, but there are some real cheap ones there to be found. The selection, especially for this small store, is large, and there is a sizable dvd collection as well. This place is definitely worth checking out. Also, I don’t know what that other reviewer was smoking or drinking, but the owner DOES NOT have an attitude. He is actually a very friendly guy. Also, this location was NEVER a Mr. Cheapo’s. The Mr. Cheapo’s that closed was over in East Meadow on Hempstead Turnpike. And by the way, Mr. Cheapo’s IS another great place to shop for music. (but that’s for another review!)

Usually they have what I want. If they don’t, they can get it. Used vinyl is always great quality. Great prices. Excellent customer service!

Skip this one. Terrible pricing. Attitude. Used to be the other Mr Cheapos which speaks volumes. Saw the cheapos owner in there today so they probably changed the name to lose the bad rep. Not fooling anyone. Go hit Infinity for a way better experience.