Anderson’s Frozen Custard

The only item on the menu I can offer a review of is the classic vanilla custard. It’s AMAZING. So eggy and creamy, and the best vanilla taste. Portions are big!
Hopefully we’ll get around to trying their food options soon! Definitely a great location here on the boulevard.

Love their ice-​cream. Good taste and consistency. Enjoyed it. Will go back. Fast moving lines and clean

Biggest rip off ever!!! $ 9.50 for a small roast beef sandwich, small fry and small drink. This place is a joke. I wish I could leave 0 stars, because that’s what this place deserves. And I had to wait 10 mins in the drive thru, when I was the only person here… If you’re going to spend this much money you might as well just go to Ted’s hot dogs next door. At least you’ll be full when you’re done eating!

I go here for lunch with co-​workers and always enjoy everything!
Their roast beef, baked potatoes and ice cream are my ultimate favorites!
Favorite flavor ice cream is the Peanut Butter chip frozen yogurt –its soooo good!

Carls choice Roast beef is always good. Surprisingly some of the best in the area. Side of Cheddar with the seasoned fries are a home run.

+ best frozen custard around!
We stopped by here on Friday night at around 8:00pm and it wasn’t busy at all. We ordered a cone and hot fudge sundae. Both were super good! I like the consistency of the custard, very creamy and thick. Both chocolate and vanilla taste wonderful. Service was good and the place is clean with lots of seating. Super fast free wi-​fi too. I’m hooked!

A true local treat and delicacy in the Western, NY/​Buffalo, NY region. Delicious Beef on Weck as it is called. Otherwise, known also as roast beef on a kilmmeiweck roll. It is unbelievable. The delicious taste of the roast beef on that very tasty roll is an absolute must taste if you are in Buffalo, NY. They serve the awesome curly Q fries as well, awesome indeed! Being a former resident of the Upstate NY area for many years, I find that over the years, places like Anderson’s are becoming harder and harder to find in the United States. It is a true local foodie place and trust me, after reading this review you will thank me because not just the delicious beef on weck but also the custard that is home made at Anderson’s is delicious as well. Highly recommend their chocolate vanilla twist from this place, it is awesome. But back to the beef on weck, this place is great for it and has been known in the Buffalo area for a long, long time. I highly recommend to eat here whether you are a local or just visiting the great city of Buffalo, NY and its surrounding areas, this is surely the place to grab your beef on weck!

My first time having frozen custard and I’m hooked! I tried the cinnamon flavor with chocolate sauce which was simply amazing.

Super crowded on summer nights. I love all Anderson’s eateries– beef, curly fries, custard. This location even has a drive-​thru! Only complaint is that the parking lot can be a nightmare. Otherwise, I love Anderson’s!

Never enjoyed Frozen custard so much till I got to buffalo and discovered Anderson’s!
My favority flavor is probably frozen custard pistachio flavor, the butter cream flavor is not something I personally would recommend.
I do not really like the onion rings here Buffalo Wild Wings have better ones.

Neo from The Matrix and Pamela Denise opened this place, and never looked back.
Anderson’s is excellent. The portions are small and they’re a tiny bit overpriced, so don’t go if you’re starving. But it’s a fantastic place for kids. The Buffalo Chicken Tender Sandwich is juicy and delicious. The Roast Beef on Weck is not bad. The rest of the fare is good.
The best BOW sandwich is at Charlie The Butchers by the airport, and a lot of the bars have good, big wholesome ones too (such as Audobon North near this Anderson’s), but in terms of a good place to take kids, that has ice cream and kids stuff, this would definitely be up there. It has a bit of that kitch 50s thing going on, and I like that. Also, while I despise chains, this is a local chain (particular to Buffalo), much like Ted’s or Avenue Pizza (I’m not mentioning Mighty Taco because I can’t stand it, and it may as well be Taco Bell), and local chains are only one step below standalone local eateries on the «I can feel good about spending my money here» meter.
I always got the Buffalo Chicken Tender Sandwich partly because it was cheap, and partly because it tastes damn good and the chicken is usually piping hot and juicy as hell. Utterly delicious, with the hot sauce and all. If there are 2 criticisms of this wondrous sandwich, one would be that their Buffalo sauce is more like straight Hot Sauce (or similar to Anchor Bar’s or Duff’s wing sauce) rather than being buttery, orangey and Buffalonian. The other would be that sometimes, at this location in particular, the lettuce they put on the sandwich is, for lack of a better word, congealed. When they get their veggies fresh, they turn me on a lot more.
The Tully’s Buffalo Chicken Tender Dinner is better than this Chicken Tender Sandwich, but it’s 5 times the size and twice the price so if you want a little snack and somewhere that is kid friendly, bring them here. The girls that work in Tully’s are hot, bartender-​esque. The girls that work in Anderson’s mostly look about 15. I think if you’re over 15, you can’t get hired here. You also can’t watch sports on TV here, but then that’s probably part of the appeal.
Their frozen custard is pretty good. It’s not Bill Grays but it will do just fine :) It’s huge, it tastes great, and it’s dirt cheap (especially compared to the food items). Anderson’s is a Buffalo specialty. You won’t get full on Anderson’s, so you can hit this place and the Ted’s next door in one trip if you want to sample Buffalo’s 2 most famous local chains.
You have to love those all-​American places with the shakes and the burgers and the fast food ambience with the local-​diner charm, with the summer opening hours and the 50s music and the jukebox and the low prices and the high school girls working there as their summer jobs and the families sitting in booths recreating Pleasantville. It’s something you just can never recreate in any country other than the USA. I’ve seen other nations try it, but I’ve never seen it work. It’s pretty much what America is famous for, food wise. Among other things.
Pautler’s does the kitch American fast food better than Anderson’s, but they’re in the same mold. Ish.

Since this is a local chain near my hotel, I decided to try one of Buffalo’s famous beef on weck and some of Anderson’s frozen custard all at one location.
The sandwich is like some kind of roll with salt chunks on top with roast beef. Pretty good, something new and interesting to try. A little too pricey and barely filling in my opinion.
The frozen custard was very delicious though! They had different choices for frozen custard, frozen yogurt, ice cream … Great place to take your kids out for cheap dessert.
I had the chocolate and vanilla swirl frozen custard, which has a thicker consistency than frozen yogurt. Its more of a creamier and richer version of Costco’s vanilla-​chocolate frozen yogurt swirl, haha. Nothing super amazing.

This one is for you, Sam P. I would have NEVER thought to review anything in Buff, and now I find myself trying to make a list of my old time favorites.
I don’t particularly like sweets. I don’t like ice-​cream at all. I used to come here multiple times a week despite all that, and not just because I lived a short 10 minute walk away.
Ok, I shouldn’t lie I used to drive. No one walks in Buff — it’s almost as bad as taking the bus.
My drug of choice was lemon ice with strawberries. It’s like heaven on earth. A cool breeze on a scorching day. A kiss from a beautiful stranger. A Gucci sample sale.
Why are you still at your computer? Go!