Mr P Pizza & Pasta

So I stopped in today to see if anything had improved because I was hoping to grab a slice.
It is really unfortunate how they do things here. They must have 15 pizzas sitting out on the counter all in varying levels of staleness. I asked the older gentleman behind the counter if maybe they had something that had recently came out of the oven and he looked over the old pizzas and said no. Everything sitting out looked old and dry.
I refuse to eat junk food that isn’t fresh and tasty. I’ve officially given up on this place.

Great spot. Pizza is consistently good and the service is quick. Not to mention how nice the staff is – I highly recommend this place.

Everything was notibly fresh. The portions are large and right priced. The staff is very friendly. We will definitely be back.

I have eaten at Mr. Ps many times. I think they have one of the best turkey hoagies. I had dinner there, this past Tuesday night. I ordered a chicken parm. and pasta. The chicken was not edible. I am not sure what it was, it was either raw or something else. I couldn’t cut or chew it. There was a film over the chicken. I informed the waitress and her reply was, «oh». That is not good business practice. An apology and perhaps offering taking something off the bill. I have mixed feelings about returning. I am disappointed.

This was about two years ago. My friends and I, along with our children, all stopped in for dinner one evening. We were four adults and four children. We all ordered drinks which were served promptly. We then ordered our food. We got to talking and eventually realized it had been 45 minutes since we ordered! It wasn’t busy — half the tables were empty — but our waitress was nowhere to be found.
I went up to the counter and asked about our food. They looked confused and told me we hadn’t ordered any. They offered to take my order a second time, but I declined and asked to just pay for the drinks. The kids were getting bored and antsy and it was a school night, so we couldn’t stay longer.
Well, that’s when it went from bad to worse. The guy behind the counter who I assume was the owner got FURIOUS. He started yelling at me to just leave. I pointed out that I hadn’t paid for the drinks yet. «Don’t bother. Get out!»
???
All this in front of my kids and friends and the other patrons in the restaurant. I asked «What is your problem?» He said, «You are a bad person!» Uh. Ok. Because I can’t wait any longer for the food you forgot to make? I told him he was nuts and ushered my kids out the door.
Needless to say, we have never been back.

Got delivery last night the girl answering the phone told us 30 minutes it took an hour and a half to get there. We understood because they probaly got busy and we weren’t to upset about that, just hungry! The food arrived cold and mess! I ordered chicken parm dinner. The breaking on the ¼ thick chicken all fell off and the pasta was just sitting in a bowl of watery red sauce. It was so unappetizing and not flavored at all. My husband ordered a Stromboli and that was cold but he said was also not flavored and tasted like it was cooked previously and just sat. We will definitely not be giving them anymore of our business. Just plain gross food!

Our go to pizza place. Reminds me of board walk pizza. Everyone there has always been very friendly and we’ve never had any issues with their pizza and fries.

Usually good pasta but pizza failure tonight.
If pizza is your name perhaps a little pride in the product you supply.
Also got a cheese steak stromboli no flavor it was as if the steak was boiled $ 17.00 for a long roll with boiled beef. Not their best showing

Best Pizza by far. As a Native New Yorker I’m always looking for NY style Pizza. Been living in the area for 7 years now and nothing even comes close. In addition to their plain pizza they offer a full menu of great food. Great family atmosphere & great staff.

I LOVE LEFT OVER PIZZA… that’s been sitting out for hours. I came by after class around 4:30pm. I usually stop in around lunch time, that’s when their Pizza are really good. Otherwise 4:30pm pizza sucks! It’s dried out and the flavors are gone. After paying for my pizza and waiting for it to heat up in their oven, one of their cooks was cleaning up the front counter and saw my waiting. I made eye contact with him, then he rudely asked me, «yo buddy what are you waiting for?» I procede to tell him I was waiting for my pizza that’s heating in the oven. The little guy just walks away. The cashier lady was way more friendlier then that guy. I don’t know if I would ever come back.

Good pizza, great fried donuts… friendly staff

I’ve always had great food here ! Best chicken Cesar salad around with real grilled chicken breast. The salad is huge and delicious. My other favorite is their white pizza with ricotta ! Service is fast and friendly too!

Great pizza place, lots of variety. I stop by here whenever I’m in the area.

Yuck! Nothing worse then bad pizza. Greasy and lack of flavor make this a place I will not be returning to.

A great place for a pizza or a full meal. The service is great and the rolls are the best

Terrible Pizza, it lacks any and all flavor. However what saves this place is the staff, they were super friendly from start to finish, service was quick (but I mean we were the only ones there) but I’ve seen pizza place workers often drag their ass in this same sort of scenario, so that I appreciate. Perhaps the Pasta @ Mister P’s is much better?