Miss Lucy’s Restaurant

Have been going for years but sad to say it’s been going downhill. Last time was last time will go. Food bad time to get order over 1:45 and came out cold. We were there Jan31

Grabbed lunch. Beachside view is often. Service was good. Price comparable with the rest of the island. I would recommend.
Only concern… red algae in summer. Not the most pleasant of smells if wind shifts. Not a major issue during our lunch.

Beautiful dining seaside under the trees with some unusual dinner companions (baby goats, cats, chickens). I had the fish Ruben and it was very good. Quinoa salad is good too. Can’t beat the view.

Before I say anything, I want to note that the 5-​star review excludes service. I’ll get to that in a second, but if you want something quick, head elsewhere.
It’s wise to call ahead and get a reservation to eat here. It’s not that crowded, but the kitchen is tiny and the waitstaff is too.
Seating is right on the water. Literally. There”s also goats and cats that wander up as you’re eating. It’s pretty weird, but hey it’s great.
The bar is pretty quick, which is a godsend. Our food took nearly 90 minutes to come out. The appetizers took around 60, but it was all okay. We had nowhere else to be and the evening was wonderful.
There was only one waitress and the moment we sat down she told us that it would be a while, as is always the case. There’s only about 10 tables, but they can only make food so fast I guess.
Pretty much every place in the Caribbean makes conch fritters, but I’ve never had any that were better than the ones served here. Same with the Johnny Cakes.
Our group of 6 got a variety of options, and having tried all of them, none were bad at all. In fact, they all were about 5 stars. The paella is probably the best on the menu.
If you want a whole evening to relax right by the water and enjoy an amazing meal, this is probably the best place on the island.