Arcata Pizzeria

This is the worst pizza place I’ve ever been too, I have given it 3 chances. Each time a fail!
1. They don’t make poutines with gravy. It’s with pizza sauce. Disgusting.
2. The cheese on my pizza was so burnt.
3. I ordered a calzone and it doesn’t even come with sauce! They said the is sauce inside. Who doesn’t give sauces with a calzone?
I do NOT recommend this place… I will definitely not be back.

Arcata Pizza is my go to pizza place when I’m in the mood for pizza. The pizza is always and I mean always exactly the same. I’ve never once and said, «the last one was better, or this one is better». They are consistent in their pizza, quality, taste and price. The staff are very friendly both on the phone and in the restaurant, always pleasant with a smile.
My only criticism of Arcata is that if you are ordering a pizza for delivery in the cold and winter months, don’t. The delivery personnel always bring the pie to the door without the pizza bag. Furthermore, they wait until the transactions have cleared before handing it over. Therefore, by the time we get the pizza into the house it is lukewarm to cold. Except for that, it is a great pizza. I tend to forego delivery in the colder months and opt for pick-​up, this way I can ensure a hot pizza for family dinner.

Their pizza sauce is amazing! The cheese isn’t rubbery like many other pizzas I’ve tried. I don’t usually eat halal pepperoni but from here it’s so flavorful! I recommend fresh mushrooms and halal pepperoni! Awesome place, I truly appreciate their realness in their food

Nothing special. I ordered for delivery to my hotel room, was told 45 minutes to an hour. I called at an hour and 10 minutes, was told it should be there. Took another 20 minutes. Pizza was not hot, more like warm at best. Prices are stiff for what you get. Quality was average at best. Go elsewhere.

Being from Windsor, I’ve been getting pizza from Arcata for as long as I can remember. Whenever my brother would visit from Toronto, getting Arcata pizza would always be the first thing he wanted to do when he walked in the door because there is no place in Toronto that makes pizza as good as this.
The pizza is delicious and made with home-​made ingredients. There is a lot of ingredients to choose from and they are very accommodating with what you want (i.e. bacon on one side, ham on the other, peppers on both etc.) The crust is thick and doughy. It’s obviously made with care. I find so many times at other pizza places they don’t cook the pizza enough. Here, that never happens. It’s perfect every time. They don’t use a ton of sauce. Nothing’s worse than a too saucy pizza.
They have other things on the menu as well: appetizers, pastas, garlic bread etc. I’ve never tried any of these, however.
My 2 complaints:
1. It’s kind of expensive, and the prices seem to keep going up.
2. The last time I went there to pick it up, I came on time but I still had to wait a long time still.