Chicago Eatery

Toronto, Canada

3.9

Closed now

11 reviews

Free Wi-Fi

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 416-519-2023
Website:
www.chicagoeatery.ca
Address:
919 Pape Avenue, Toronto, ON, M4K 3V3
East York
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
240 ftPape Avenue
270 ftMortimer Avenue
760 ftCarlaw Avenue
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
Yes
Delivery
Yes
Take-out
No
Accepted Cards
Credit, Debit
Bike Parking
Yes
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
Yes
Attire
Casual
Noise Level
Average
Alcohol
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Wi-Fi
Free
Has TV
Yes

Today

Today 11:30 am – 11:00 pm
Closed now
Local time (Toronto) 10:37 Thursday, 22 May 2025

Business hours

Monday 11:30 am – 11:00 pm
Tuesday 11:30 am – 11:00 pm
Wednesday 11:30 am – 11:00 pm
Thursday 11:30 am – 11:00 pm
Friday 11:30 am – 11:00 pm
Saturday 11:30 am – 11:00 pm
Sunday 11:30 am – 10:00 pm

Description

Specialties

High Quality Fresh Food, Smoked Meats, Steaks, Bison Burgers. Unique twist on American Cuisine.

History

Established in 2015.

Bringing something new to East York, Chicago Eatery is a casual dining spot with a unique twist on American cuisine. With high quality steaks, amazing bison burgers and a large variety from the smoker all served in large portions, the menu and ambiance guarantees an excellent dining experience.

Related places

Explore similar places:
230
ft
California Restaurant & Tavern
914 Pape Ave (East York)
1
mi
Lolita’s Lust
513 Danforth Avenue (Greektown, Riverdale)
1
mi
Detroit Eatery
389 Danforth Ave (Greektown, Riverdale)
1
mi
Big Moe’s Pape
1042 Pape Avenue (East York)
1
mi
Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen
523 Danforth Avenue (Greektown, Riverdale)
1
mi
Whistler’s Restaurant
995 Broadview Ave (East York)

Nearby

Near this location:
50
ft
Bill’s Midway Auto Body
919 Pape Avenue
90
ft
S-Mart
911 Pape Ave
90
ft
My Dog Spot
911 Pape Avenue
100
ft
Aiello Carlo Invstmt
878 Pape Avenue
120
ft
Silverplate Press
882 Pape Avenue
120
ft
Frog’s Gym
909 Pape Avenue

11 reviews of Chicago Eatery

No registration required
Place rating: 5
L'Amable, Canada
Fund this place in early December, dropping off a friend, in her hood.
Our intention was to just pop in for a beer, but we decided to try the smoked rib sliders and shrimp poppers. SO glad we did.
Some of the best ribs I have ever had in a restaurant.
Went back there two weeks later to have the rib meal with a Delish side salad — the salad was fresh crisp spinach with cranberries, dressing could have had a bit more of a tang, but everything else was fantastic.
It’s clean, stylish, and the service is attentive and friendly, without being invasive.
I plan on being a repeat customer!
Next time I am bringing a group of friends to try their Vodka party shot service, and the bison burger.
Place rating: 3
Toronto, Canada
Came here on a weekday night, nice and clean inside. This place has changed over to a couple of different restaurants and it seems like they are not having much luck still.
Restaurant is 90% empty everyday, have never seen it packed. The last time it was packed was when it was a burger joint with the original Greek owners called Kings Court. Since selling the business and building years ago, they moved back to Greece to retire. Unfortunately, that same year they moved back they were killed in a car accident. Now the place seems like it can’t seem to resurrect to being the packed restaurant it once was.
This place would be awesome if it was a California Sandwiches, would make a killing or an awesome burger joint.
New, young staff to breathe excitement.
Food was good, I had the cheese steak — too much jalapeño…over kill, good sandwich still.
I’d come here to do a pick up next time.
Place rating: 5
Toronto, Canada
Was just there with my wife amazing food great service try the chicken sandwich with avocado
Place rating: 4
Toronto, Canada
Came here after passing it for sometime now.
Glad we decided to stop in and give it a go…
Service was wonderful as our waitress was very helpful by letting us know what was recommend as this was our first time there.
To start we ordered the shrimp app which was very delicious, I would totally order it again.
I had the Salmon main that was served with dill sauce, salad and veggies, this dish was amazing! I was very pleased with it and would again return just to have that dish.
My boyfriend ordered the half rack of ribs and sweet potato fries, in which he said the ribs were on the dry side but good.
We both loved the patio as it was a lovely summer evening to enjoy, we were surprised it wasn’t packed with people.
Overall we will return as we live around the corner and both enjoyed our experience as we found the both the food and service to be excellent.
Place rating: 2
Toronto, Canada
We’ve eaten there a few times it has never been busy but always good until yesterday. The place was empty yet we waited forever for our food that wasn’t any good and my burger wasn’t even dressed right. What could have been a gem of the neighbourhood has turned into a flop. Definitely overpriced for the service and quality. It is worth the walk to the Danforth.
Place rating: 5
Toronto, Canada
My God! Some of the best ribs I’ve had hands down! Wife had the dry rubbed smoked chicken breast and swears it is the best she’s ever had. Fantastic food and the staff are incredible. Fun, friendly and warm. It felt like eating at a family member’s place. Oh… did I mention the flambé for dessert!!! Every bit as good as mom’s. Must try restaurant!!!
Place rating: 4
Toronto, Canada
We live in the area and have wanted to try this newly renovated restaurant for a while. We went with a group of 8 people and we were all impressed. The food was delicious and the service was excellent! I had the salmon, hubby had the bison burger. We also really enjoyed the shrimp poppers as an appetizer. We will return!
Place rating: 5
Toronto, Canada
I was really impressed!
The quality of food is very good, a solid 8/​10, maybe higher (we only tried one thing) and the portion size was larger than expected. The Smoked-​Beer braised brisket sandwich had meat piled up, so much so that I used a fork first to get it down to a manageable eating by hand size.
The patio is great and even though it is on a busy road (pape), the stone faced walls with glass top cuts out most of the road noise. Having an easily heard conversation even when at the road-​side table as we were isn’t a problem at all.
There was talk of them potentially having some live music as well so I really hope that happens. I’d be a regular!
Place rating: 4
West End, Vancouver, Canada
No draft beer.
But smoked meat and ribs in house.
The shrimp appy is DELICIOUS. And all appys are ½ price before 4pm — along with domestic beers for $ 4
All n all. Tasty stuff and cheap drinks.
The patio could use some plants — but it’s not a deal killer.
Place rating: 2
Toronto, Canada
The place is nice, but the food is very underwhelming. A little pricey as well. They don’t have draft beer. This is bizarre given its a Chicago themed restaurant. I ordered the cheese steak sandwich and it was bizarre. Open faced sandwich LOADED with red peppers. No salt or pepper. We ordered ribs as well and they were extremely dry. The espresso was unbelievably expensive for the size. It wasn’t even a mouth full of espresso.
Place rating: 4
Toronto, Canada
Great addition to our community! Love the atmosphere, friendly service. Great food! Can’t wait for the patio to open!