Micatoni’s

Great quality products and service, but MAN OH MAN are the prices ever quite high here. The meats are not very competitive in price when compared to other (dedicated) butcher shops around town.
I get it, I’m not paying grocery store, pre-​packaged prices for grocery store-​pre-​packaged meat, but there are a lot of other options at much better prices.

Best meat in town. Mike and Tony (owners) are great guys. Their steaks are mouthwatering, and you’ve never had chicken like this before — incredible mennonite poultry.
«Steak it easy!»

It’s not good… It’s Amazing! Sandwiches are very delicious, steak done perfectly, to order. Good food, warm atmosphere and kind staff will always greet you there.
Fresh meat on the higher price range, but worth it, you get what you pay for.

The people who work here are friendly– my positive review ends here.
The sandwiches were tiny and looked nothing like other reviewer’s pictures.
Beef brisket sandwich: at most 3 VERY thin slices of bland, slightly tough brisket on a soggy bun
Pulled beef sandwich: the meat was greasy, not flavorful and again a soggy bun
Had some of the worst deli sandwiches of my life here, not sure if things have changed since all these previous reviews (they make this place sound fantastic– so much so that I went 25 minutes out of the way to try this place)
Very disappointing– won’t be back.

I just went to Micatoni’s for the first time a few days ago to try their Pulled Chicken sandwich, as per the advice of fellow posters. Unfortunately my experience was not good at all. I was really hungry when I got my sandwich and I took two big bites and right away I thought the sandwich was extremely salty. After another bite though I noticed that the chicken had a slight day old type of taste to it, so I immediately stopped eating it and threw it out. About 2 hours later my stomach started turning and I threw up. That sandwich was the only thing I ate and I wasn’t sick prior to that. So Obviously I will not be returning ever again. Its not worth the risk at all.

Their sandwiches are really good, my favorite one is the Brisket with barbecue sauce. It is a must go place for sandwich.

Love their beef brisket and steak sandwiches here! They cook the steak per order and you better eat it right away while it’s piping hot!

The owner is very friendly and engages new and old customers alike. Excellent customer service from him. The rest of his staff are younger guys and their service is good but they’re less aware of their customers.
The store is very small and usually has a few people inside. They have a hot table, a butchers table, dry goods and some frozen and refrigerated premade goods. There is a table by the window with a few seats if you want to eat a quick sandwich there.
The owner states they offer grass fed beef and other high quality healthy meat choices that they get from a supplier he has shopped around for. I saw an eddystone Meats truck out front once so I’ll bet that’s where he gets his meat from which is not a cheap place at all.
I’ve only had a few things on their menu as everything is quite expensive (but I’d say worth it). The beef brisket sandwich has a lot of liquid which makes the bread pretty soggy but it has a great flavour. The extra toppings are expensive but very very good. I’ve been charged for some sometimes and not at other times so I’m a little confused on their policy.
I’ve also tried some of their frozen food… the veal lasagna was nice but small and quite expensive. The mannicotti was nothing special. There was some fresh Mac and cheese which looked really awesome although it was quite expensive as well.
All in all it is a great shop in the area as long as you can afford it. Considering the area, I’ll bet a lot of people can. There really isn’t any competitors that I’ve found other than maybe longos and if you believe that grass fed beef is healthier then once again there isn’t really any competitors.

Phenomifukal sandwich new found love
Pulled chicken sandwich was like a slice of heaven
My buddy says the veal blows the doors off California sandwiches
Will be back

Saw this location on Eat Here York Region & then read all the reviews on Unilocal.
We were helped by one of the owners… Superb service! We purchased meats etc… And then we could not leave without trying their sandwiches.
OMG delicious!!! We had the pulled beef as well as the brisket. Both had the coleslaw and Mad Mayo… both were scrumptious!!! Moving forward we will purchase our meats from this location and will not leave without grabbing one of their delicious sandwiches. Service was GR8!!! Overall a very positive experience! Thanks to everyone who posted.

It’s a butcher shop with a little take away counter in the back.
I had the beef brisket w/​onions, hot peppers and it was so so good!
I could eat the brisket all day with a big plate of rice.
I’ll be back for the steak sandwich.

Simply delicious!!! You have to try their pre seasoned uncooked lemon chicken and hot brisket sandwich!!!
Super friendly staff and can’t say enough about the cleanliness of this neighbourhood jem!
Highly recommend it!

Love their veal sandwich. This place is close to home so I’d like to try their meats soon. I’ve purchased bone marrow from here as well, and they slice in length wise for you!

It’s rare to find a sandwich place where the entire menu is off the charts. Each and every sandwich is incredible, from beef brisket to pulled pork to veal cutlet. The bread is fresh daily and has an amazing crusty outside to hold in all the juices of your meat of choice. I think the most remarkable thing is all sandwiches are $ 6.99! (Keep in mind it’s a high-​end butcher shop too so I’m guessing that’s where they make their money)
Absolutely the best choice for a sandwich, far better than any other panini/​sandwich shop in the area

Visiting from out of the country, and staying in the area. Checked out some local Unilocal reviews for a lunch spot. Decided to give Micatoni’s a try, and so glad we did.
Tried the brisket, chicken, pork, and meatballs. Everyone loved it, including the kids.

Beef brisket for $ 7.99 and an overall rating of 5 stars on Unilocal.I went the very next day after finding this place. Its a different take on beef brisket for me. I’m use to have the smoked beef brisket at BBQ joints. Not sure what cooking style they used here but the beef was soft and tender and was swimming in a soup of amazing sauce.
Don’t even think about getting this sandwich to go. Its just so juicy that every second counts. By the time I took my first bite at the bar stools in the front of the store the bread was already getting soggy. The outer part of the bread still had a nice crunch though. Amazing beef brisket and I was tempted to go for another sandwich seeing as how good the first one was. I talked myself out of getting a second sandwich because I need to start watching my weight, plus there was a bakery right down the road so I had to save space for some sweets.
Service was excellent and friendly.

Had the Beef Brisket Sandwich… it left me wanting more and more and more. Can’t say much about the Chicken Parm… but that Brisket so good. it makes me wanna smack your momma!

Absolutely awesome place to buy your meat and lunch/​dinner! They have everything from four cuts of steak to their own special marinated ribs! Lots of lunch meats to choose from and amazing brisket!!! I took other reviewers advice and ordered the brisket and rolls separately so it wouldn’t go soggy for tonight’s dinner. I also ordered the rice balls, the pulled beef and meat balls! The Mennonite Turkey was fabulous and the salami was as well!!! All nitrate and preservative free!!!
Very friendly and helpful! A lot to take in one first visit! I will definitely be back!

Just went in with my brother, got some veal shanks and the beef brisket sandwich which I had to try because of all the great reviews, it was amazing! Brisket was cooked to perfection, melt in your mouth fresh. Will definitely be back!

July 20, 2014
Finally had chance to get the steak sandwich here. Took probably 5 minutes to make… Took me 3 minutes to finish it. Don’t get me wrong, size of sandwich was pretty decent and the meat portion was very generous compared to other places, it was just that good!
Steak was seasoned very well and very tender. No complaints at all.
Price of the sandwich came out to be $ 9 (well worth it).
My only tip/​suggestion, eat sandwich on the spot! If you are taking it home, there is a chance that it might get a bit soggy.