Pizza Garden

I read these reviews and had high expectations. Pizza arrived much earlier than informed by phone but it was verging on cold. The crust was excellent, nice and chewy, and the sauce was very good (not too much sauce!) but some of the other topping were sparse. Not very many mushrooms, not a lot of cheese and I would question whether that was prosciutto or just plain luncheon meat ham. Overall, I’ve had better. Price was good though and debit at the door is always nice.

I love the pizza here. Nice folks that run it. Very pleasant and the variety of choices of slices is awesome.

Website doesn’t seem to be working…

Best pizza in New West! We had the Margherita and the Supremo and they were both great. Really nice thin crust. I had never eaten here before, but it’s way better than the other choices in the neighborhood. We called in our order and delivery was really quick. It’s a bit more expensive but worth it.

This is the most authentic wood-​stone oven pizza I have ever tasted and what makes it even better is that it’s local. I highly recommend this place!

Best Pizza in New West! Takes a little while to deliver but it’s always worth it.

Best pizza by far in New Westminster, especially for the price! The staff is super friendly and it’s always delivered super quickly. Definitely a great deal for quality pizza. Hard for us to ever order from anywhere else!

The absolute best pizza in New West. Authentic toppings and flavours and you can’t beat the taste of a pizza cooked in a wood-​fired oven. The only reason they didn’t get 5 stars is that they don’t notify you when your pizza is on it’s way when you order online and they can get a little hectic when it’s busy and forget your order.

Loved this pizza place for its thin-​crust, tasty sauce and good toppings. Pricing is reasonable too. A bit hard to find the first time as I didn’t realize it was on top floor of a breeze-​thru mall. But now that we know where, we will be back!

I love the pizza! The crust is SO good. It’s my one and only place I order from.
The online ordering is so easy and quick! They take debit at delivery!

We have to say we were both impressed with the super quick delivery and how superb our pizza was. We have tried basically all the pizza places in New Westminster, and though none were bad, nothing compared to Pizza Garden. We ordered a 18″ Montebello, and with delivery was under $ 25. The pizza was baked in a wood fired oven, with a Neapolitan style, hand tossed crust, with fresh toppings. THIS is how pizza should taste. Arrived piping hot too. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!

This place charges for a cup of water so right off the bat I’m not impressed. The pizza is good but the freshness is questionable. Perhaps I went at the end of the night and thy didn’t want to fire up the oven. Regardless, I won’t be back. Water should always be free or at least fifty cents for the styrofoam cup. Boo.

This is by far the best pizza by the slice restaurant around… my family loves this place and the service is excellent.

Awesome pizzas, especially for the price you pay. They lose some marks for being salty for their meat slices.

I would give a 5 star rating except for not being sent an email notifying me the pizza is on the way. But it’s always delicious and a great price so I order from here all the time. Especially since they’re one of the few places that delivers into queensborough near midnight!
I always build my own veggie pizza (choosing different peppers, tomatoes, mushrooms and cheeses each time) and the ingredients are always fresh tasting and wonderfully cooked.
Highly recommended!

Holy moly this place is delicious!!!
We bought an extra large pizza with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms and extra cheese. It was amazing!
It didn’t make you feel like garbage either, like many of the big chains do.
It was super delicious. We try not to eat food like this very often, but it will be a nice treat once in a while!

Fast delivery of good tasty pizza. My default place for ordering delivery food.
Wished they were a little more accommodating for ordering custom toppings. Online menu isn’t very helpful.

I’ve been ordering from the New West pizza garden for a while now, their Neapolitan style pizza is amazing.
The last time I ordered they mixed up my order with another persons, as I live in a townhouse building we share the same address. To apologize they gave me a $ 5 discount coupon, great right?
I attempted to use the coupon today, I called in and placed my order. I told the person that I had the coupon, they said it’s fine and to just give it to the delivery driver. The coupon says «$ 5.00 discount on your next purchase of any regular priced Large Specialty Pizza» I ordered a ‘Large Pepperoni’ and they delivered an Extra-​Large.
When I noticed the size and price difference I asked the delivery driver. He told me that they only have Medium and Extra-​Large. It seems odd that they would somehow leap from Medium to Extra large with no Large in between, even though the coupon specifies that it’s Large, and not Extra or Medium.
He said that large means Extra large to them. But their website doesn’t specify sizes in words, only inches. He told me that when I ordered large they assumed Extra large, and that because the coupon says Large it doesn’t say Medium. But with that same logic that means it doesn’t say Extra.
He ended up taking the pizza back, and they are re-​making me a ‘Medium’ one now, he insisted on taking the coupon back with him and that I would still receive the discount.

I am addicted to the pizza here. Whoever gives this place less than a 5 doesn’t understand what good pizza should taste like, and they probably rate Old Spaghetti Factory with 5 stars.
I mean seriously, who doesn’t like pizza here? Fresh AND amazing ingredients, like gorgonzola, sun dried tomatoes, pesto sauce, basil… oh my gawwdddd just typing these up makes me want to go back and run to get some more. This place will truly put more pounds on me this year unless I strain myself from going to that place. I can’t help myself. I’m so addicted to this place.
I don’t think I’ll ever go back to other pizza places… and that’s a strong statement. It’s been a long and difficult journey to find a good local pizza place, and I’ve finally found the place. Good bye, Pizza Hut. Good bye, Fresh Slice (HAH!). Good bye, Uncle Fatih (I hear gasps somewhere far away…). Good bye, California Pizza Place. Good bye, Round Table.
Just FYI, this place is warm 24/​7, 365 days. The pizza oven that they use is legit pizza oven, so you’re gonna feel the heat all day. Personally, I feel bad for the people who work there… it’s just so warm…

F*ck fruit, this pizza belongs in the Garden of Eden.
Though Uncle Fatih still makes some damn fine slices of pie, Pizza Garden is my new favourite joint. Being a huge fan of the Uncle, this revelation took several visits to admit to myself.
Oddly enough, the founder of Pizza Garden also started the Megabite chain, though the two are from different Gods completely.
Using 100% Italian Caputo flour and a wood stone (gas powered, not firewood) oven, these guys and gals make everything fresh to order. No mass prepping like other guys.
The thin crust has the perfect amount of crispiness and chewiness that will make you say ‘f*ck, this is good sh*t’.
Though nearly every variety of tried is damn good, my favourites are Capicola, Hawaiian, Ground Beef and one I can’t remember that name (has parsley on it).
Doesn’t hurt that all the staff are super passionate and friendly. Fun to watch these guys feed the oven.
At only $ 2.25/slice GST-​in, it’s a god damn steal.
Every visit has gotten better which is perfect. Higher turnover = constant freshness and wicked selection.
If New West is too far, check out their Commercial Drive or Downtown (Smithe) locations.
Praise the lord.