Amici’s Pizzeria

I don’t usually write reviews. I don’t like to attach my name or face to anything at risk damaging my business. My business is based on my word honesty and trust and the truth. Unless I believe in a place and like it 100%. I won’t write a review. That’s why this is only my second review so far.
I don’t eat fast food. Not because its bad for you. It’s because its taste like trash. Low quality tastless, substandard, things that resembles food. Looks and taste the way dog food smells. I haven’t eaten Mc Donalds, pizza pazza, and other fast food places in 4 years. I hate all chain food, frozen tasteless garbage, I’d rather eat the bag it came in. I’m very picky in what I eat. I’m a bit of a food snob.
This place is amazing, flavorful, fresh. The pizza taste like it was fresh from Italy. I even eat the crust. And the wings… Medium are same as the New York butter, but better. I used to go to Honneys & Sam’s is Buffalo just to get wings. Not any more. These wings are better than the USA wings.
Forget about all the other chain pizza places and try this one. I come all the way from Hamilton mountain just to get their pizza and wings. My wife and 3 kids also love it. Before amichies when my wife and kids wanted pizza I would get them 1 large and a dozen wings. The kids would eat 1 slice each and 1 – 2 wings each, I would make a sandwich. Now I have to get 2 large and 40 wings and kids eat 2 — 5 slices and 4 — 8 wings each.
I’m the owner of Scott E Muma Computer repairs. If your from Hamilton you most likely know who I am.
I will garuntee you will love this place, if your not happy. I’ll give you 20% off my services. That would more than cover the cost of a pizza. So you have nothing to lose.
(Unless your favorite pizza place is Pizza Pizza, you will lose them forever after eating here)

My girlfriend and I have ordered multiple times and at the beginning the pizza was amazing. This is why we kept going back. The last few months have been a hit and miss with what you order. We don’t order anything crazy we just ask for a whole wheat pizza with think crust well done. They get it right ¹⁄₃ the time.
In the latest order We ordered a whole wheat thin crust for pickup. I showed up there at the time that was given to me for it to be ready and it was not. I ended up waiting for roughly 20 more minutes inside and they apologized. When I finally got the pizza and checked it was not whole wheat or thin crust as my girlfriend had requested over the phone. The cashier who took the order apologized and took $$ off my bill but this happens too constantly for us to go back. I also have to go home and put it in the oven for another 20 min to get it well done as requested.
Some of the pros:
–The dipping sauce is very good !
— Decent prices
— if you get stock pizza with no changes your order should be correct.
Cons:
— Any requests or extra toppings will most likely not be on final order.
— delivery takes over an hour in most cases.
— when asked for well done it still comes out soggy and needs reheating.
If you just get the pizza with no changes they can handle it and it is great. The pizza is pretty good tasting even with their competition down the street. I just think its a matter of taking orders and processing that could be improved.

New owner’s are fantastic. The guy who works the front and cooks is exceptionally pleasant, and actually cares about his food (he insisted I call him to tell him how his veal sandwich was). Pizzas are delicious, excellent tasting crust and a good sauce. The restaurant stands alone however, in it’s veal sandwich. Probably the tastiest veal in niagara, and well worth the 20 minutes I drive from stoney creek to get it. Pleasant staff who actually care about the food they serve, means that ill definitely be coming back.