I really wanted to like it, but it just wasn’t very good. There are two reasons why. First I ordered a burrito(I think it was a burrito supreme). When the server brought it, it was just a dry burrito alone on a plate — nothing else with it. I tried eating it, but the burrito was really dry and I noticed that it didn’t have all the ingredients listed in the menu. So I said to the waiter, «The Menu says there’s sour cream on this thing. Its a little dry.» He said, «No, its fine. The sour cream is inside.» So, I cut it open for him and I pointed out that there was no sour cream inside. He just shrugged his shoulders and walked away. And then, my kid had a burrito too, and with the first bite he stopped and said, «There’s a big gross tube in my burrito!» And he was right — it was pig artery or a urethra or something! Yuck! What low-quality cut of pork has arteries or urethras in it? Poor kid couldn’t eat it. Anyway, sorry guys: that’s my experience at Casa Autentica. And really, I prefer burritos without urethra.
Lynn S.
Place rating: 3 Toronto, Canada
Came here for lunch with a good friend. Owner is very friendly and allowed us to sample some of their specials. Though the food is quite authentic we did find the price quite expensive for two people for lunch. Bill came out to close to $ 50 for 2 people.
Paul J.
Place rating: 4 Keswick, Canada
Authentic Mexican food very good. Owner is very interactive with customers and fun. Lots of choices and good size portions. The«wet Burito» is very good so are the fish tacos
Nick K.
Place rating: 5 Toronto, Canada
Service here is top notch! They offer a sample plate before ordering and the food is great. The salsa is even better! They offer awesome deals on margaritas that looked good too. Try this place out!
Michelle M.
Place rating: 5 Hawthorne, CA
Great staff, got a plate of four meats to taste. The shredded beef was my favorite but the chicken with mango salsa was very good too. My favorite salsa was the chipotle. The food was great over all, loved the mixture of ingredients and reminds me of the small restaurants from Mexico. They have a variety of drinks and freshly made fruit drinks as well. I will definitely be back for more.
Daniella M.
Place rating: 1 Newmarket, Canada
Not happy with this place at all. Super expensive, like overly expensive. Portions are a joke and taste and quality, meh. To the people saying«for the authentic Mexican experience» clearly have never A. Been to Mexico(besides the tourist areas) B. Have never been to a decent Mexican Restaurant. The décor is tacky, you don’t need to entertain your guests with sombreros and cheap decorations. Tone it down and focus on the food. Food for 3 people you’re looking at $ 70 which is just nuts to me. And that’s take out. With tip eating in, oh boy. The people working there are friendly enough, but the owner is a bit pushy. He tries up selling the entire time. It’s like okay, I get it. It just gets a little too much. Overall I wouldn’t go back. If they work on their food and lower prices maybe. But until then, I’ll get authentic Mexican elsewhere.
Dmitry T.
Place rating: 2 Toronto, Canada
Food 2⁄5: blended taste, nothing special, not even spicy enough. disappointment. portions are small. They are selling water to you in bottles — they would not serve tap water, not even good water. Cheap move. Service 4⁄5: friendly, trying to joke, a little too aggressive to promote their foods. Location 4⁄5: right near road. own parking. Price 3⁄5: $$$ $ 50+ for two during lunch. will NOT be back.
Eric Z.
Place rating: 2 Bradford West Gwillimbury, Canada
I had the tuna tacos, which were very disappointing. I asked several times if the tuna was fresh and told yes, you will enjoy it. It is literally tuna from a can on three small tacos for $ 14.99 what a complete rip off. Another i thought id give them another chance. I ordered a vegetarian burrito for $ 12.99, lacking complete flavor. And the mashed potatoes they give you is literally one normal spoon full. I guess most reviewers here haven’t had good mexican food but it doesn’t take much to please small town people. I will not be back.
Natty V.
Place rating: 5 Hamilton, Canada
Great food. And great service. They are so sweet and amazing food just like being in Mexico.
Teresa T.
Place rating: 5 Midland, Canada
This Mexican restaurant serves authentic Mexican food that is delicious and oh so filling. We recommend the beef fajita and the chicken chimichanga along with the taco soup. We have visited other Mexican restaurants in the area but this is the best. The owner is friendly and humorous. This is our return visit and there will be more in the future. Gracious!
Chris R.
Place rating: 5 Georgina, Canada
Thanks for putting an authentic Mexican restaurant here. Great food. Great service. Prices are perfect. Your margaritas are terrible. Lol. But since u just for ur liquor licence I will let it slide. We are never disappointed here. I also love that you give us some recommendations. But I miss the chilli rhenos(sp). Lol
Lynette P.
Place rating: 4 Mississauga, Canada
Really cute, authentic Mexican ambience! Huge plus for this place. It feels exactly like a cantina in Mexico :) Service was great — the waitress was super attentive and made lots of suggestions. When she found out it was our first time she brought us samples of all the meats. Also my mom was cold and didn’t want a margarita or other cold drink, so the waitress offered her a coffee with Bailey’s which hit the spot for her. Speaking of margaritas… the margarita was the bomb. Not super slushy, and had some chunks of ice, but was just the right combo of lime, tequila, and salt(the best part). My mom had the fish tacos which were made with canned fish, so that was disappointing. I had the ground beef tacos which were really good. The tacos were a bit dry, and fell apart easily. But lots of toppings! On the side the mains come with garlic mashed potatoes, which were good(if a bit cold), but seemed really random as an accompaniment. My only other complaint is that they don’t give you complimentary nacho chips and salsa, which we all know is the best part about a Mexican restaurant. They have takeout combos and gift certificates where you pay $ 50 for $ 60, or $ 100 for $ 120. Me and the family will definitely be back!