The 20 Best Pizza

Ithaca, NY, United States

Show map

26 places in Ithaca, ordered by rating:

Louie’s Lunch
4.3
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 607-257-4649
Address:
500 Thurston Ave
Pizza / Sandwiches / Food Trucks
Italian Carry Out
4.3
8 reviews
Telephone:
+1 607-256-1111
Address:
1070 Danby Rd
Italian / Pizza
Ciao Wood-Fired Pizza & Pasta
4.2
21 reviews
Telephone:
+1 607-257-2233
Address:
2 Hickory Hollow Ln
Italian / Pizza
Hot Truck
3.9
19 reviews
Telephone:
+1 607-273-1111
Address:
635 Stewart Ave
Pizza / Food Trucks
Ithaca Beer Company
4.5
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 607-273-0766
Address:
122 Ithaca Beer Dr
Burgers / American (Traditional) / Pizza
Paradise Cafe
4.0
2 reviews
Telephone:
+1 607-272-2233
Address:
1601 Trumansburg Rd
Pizza /
Scale House Brew Pub
3.4
19 reviews
Telephone:
+1 607-257-0107
Address:
23 Cinema Dr
Pizza / Bars
Papa John’s Pizza
3.3
3 reviews
Telephone:
+1 607-273-7272
Address:
435 Franklin St Ste 3
Pizza /
Sal’s Pizzeria
3.6
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 607-277-7257
Address:
220 S Fulton St
Pizza / Diners
D P Dough
3.2
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 607-277-7772
Address:
114 W Green St
Pizza / Fast Food
Mark’s Pizzeria
3.4
9 reviews
Telephone:
+1 607-277-2727
Address:
222 Elmira Rd
Pizza /
Souvlaki House
3.1
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 607-273-1650
Address:
315 Eddy St
Pizza / Italian
The Connection
3.0
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 607-256-3278
Address:
310 Stewart Ave
Pizza / Fast Food
Pizza Aroma
3.2
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 607-273-6165
Address:
128 S Cayuga St
Pizza /
Pizza Hut
2.3
3 reviews
Telephone:
+1 607-257-2778
Address:
2301 N. Triphammer Rd. Cayuga Mall
Pizza / Italian / Chicken Wings
Sicilian Delight
2.1
9 reviews
Telephone:
+1 607-266-9999
Address:
40 Catherwood Rd
Italian / Pizza
Casa Blanca
2.2
16 reviews
Telephone:
+1 607-272-7777
Address:
111A E State St Ste A
Mediterranean / Pizza
Ithaca Brick Oven Pizza
···
Telephone:
+1 607-272-7500
Address:
139 Dryden Rd
Pizza /
Rogan’s Corner Northeast
···
Telephone:
+1 607-257-2757
Address:
23 Cinema Dr
Pizza /
Pizza Hut
···
Telephone:
+1 607-272-8233
Address:
344 Elmira Rd
Pizza /